PickALeague.com

2025-26 PAL Rating and Value Rating: performance and contract value

Two scores from 0 to 100, where 50 is the average NHL player. PAL Rating measures performance: offense, creation, shooting, possession, defense, discipline, power play and penalty kill, compared with players at the same position and adjusted for ice time. A defensive player isn't punished for not scoring: the score starts from the player's strength, offensive or defensive, and every player gets a profile. Salary never enters it. Value Rating answers a different question: for what the player costs, does the return come in more or less than expected?

How it's calculated →WAR, in wins →Best-value contracts →

Top forwardConnor McDavid headshot100PAL100ValueConnor McDavidEdmonton Oilers logoEDM · EliteTop defensemanEvan Bouchard headshot100PAL99ValueEvan BouchardEdmonton Oilers logoEDM · EliteTop goalieLogan Thompson headshot99PAL98ValueLogan ThompsonWashington Capitals logoWSH · Elite

Best contracts

Highest Value Rating among players rated 70 or more.

  1. 100Connor McDavidEDM · 12.50 M$ · PAL 100 (expected 77)
  2. 100Mark StoneVGK · 9.50 M$ · PAL 100 (expected 75)
  3. 100Shayne GostisbehereCAR · 3.20 M$ · PAL 99 (expected 57)
  4. 100Matthew SchaeferNYI · 0.98 M$ · PAL 98 (expected 40)
  5. 100Lane HutsonMTL · 0.95 M$ · PAL 97 (expected 39)

Heaviest contracts

Lowest Value Rating among cap hits of $5M or more.

  1. 0Chandler StephensonSEA · 6.25 M$ · PAL 0 (expected 68)
  2. 1Adin HillVGK · 6.25 M$ · PAL 2 (expected 57)
  3. 1Andre BurakovskyCHI · 5.50 M$ · PAL 2 (expected 64)
  4. 2Alexander RomanovNYI · 6.25 M$ · PAL 3 (expected 68)
  5. 2J.T. CompherDET · 5.10 M$ · PAL 5 (expected 63)

The scale — PAL Rating

  • 90–100 Elite
  • 80–89 Excellent
  • 70–79 Very good
  • 60–69 Above average
  • 40–59 Around average
  • 20–39 Below average
  • 0–19 Very poor

The scale — Value Rating

  • 90–100 Exceptional value
  • 75–89 Very good contract
  • 55–74 Good value
  • 45–54 Fair value
  • 25–44 Poor return
  • 0–24 Very poor return
#Player
1Connor McDavidEDM · F100100
2Mark StoneVGK · F100100
3Jason RobertsonDAL · F9999
4Alex DeBrincatDET · F9998
5Sam ReinhartFLA · F9998
6Brady TkachukOTT · F9999
7Nathan MacKinnonCOL · F9895
8Nikita KucherovTBL · F9897
9Matt BoldyMIN · F9896
10Brandon HagelTBL · F9898
11Seth JarvisCAR · F9896
12Cole CaufieldMTL · F9796
13Pavel DorofeyevVGK · F9799
14Nick SuzukiMTL · F9795
15Noah CatesPHI · F9797
16Leon DraisaitlEDM · F9688
17Jack HughesNJD · F9694
18Roope HintzDAL · F9694
19Tomas HertlVGK · F9692
20Kirill KaprizovMIN · F9591
21Tom WilsonWSH · F9593
22Rickard RakellPIT · F9594
23Matthew TkachukFLA · F9590
24Drake BathersonOTT · F9493
25Nico HischierNJD · F9490
26Jake GuentzelTBL · F9490
27Zach HymanEDM · F9493
28Mark JankowskiCAR · F9499
29Nikolaj EhlersCAR · F9387
30Brock NelsonCOL · F9389
31Sebastian AhoCAR · F9385
32Josh DoanBUF · F9399
33Mitch MarnerVGK · F9280
34Jack EichelVGK · F9284
35Wyatt JohnstonDAL · F9285
36Dylan LarkinDET · F9285
37Jordan KyrouSTL · F9183
38Eetu LuostarinenFLA · F9193
39Luke EvangelistaNSH · F9192
40Troy TerryANA · F9185
41Kailer YamamotoUTA · F9098
42John TavaresTOR · F9088
43Shane PintoOTT · F9089
44Noel AcciariPIT · F9094
45Connor DewarPIT · F9096
46Macklin CelebriniSJS · F8996
47David PastrnakBOS · F8974
48Nick SchmaltzUTA · F8984
49Leo CarlssonANA · F8997
50Anthony CirelliTBL · F8880

PickALeague calculation from the play-by-play and on-ice shifts of every game (NHL data) and the season's cap hits.