PickALeague.com

2023-24 PAL Rating and Value Rating: performance and contract value

Two scores from 0 to 100, where 50 is the average NHL player. PAL Rating measures performance: offense, creation, shooting, possession, defense, discipline, power play and penalty kill, compared with players at the same position and adjusted for ice time. A defensive player isn't punished for not scoring: the score starts from the player's strength, offensive or defensive, and every player gets a profile. Salary never enters it. Value Rating answers a different question: for what the player costs, does the return come in more or less than expected?

How it's calculated →WAR, in wins →Best-value contracts →

Top forwardAuston Matthews headshot100PAL100ValueAuston MatthewsToronto Maple Leafs logoTOR · EliteTop defensemanAdam Fox headshot100PAL100ValueAdam FoxNew York Rangers logoNYR · EliteTop goalieFrederik Andersen headshot99PAL98ValueFrederik AndersenCarolina Hurricanes logoCAR · Elite

Best contracts

Highest Value Rating among players rated 70 or more.

  1. 100Auston MatthewsTOR · 11.64 M$ · PAL 100 (expected 81)
  2. 100Sam ReinhartFLA · 6.50 M$ · PAL 100 (expected 75)
  3. 100Adam FoxNYR · 9.50 M$ · PAL 100 (expected 80)
  4. 100Quinn HughesVAN · 7.85 M$ · PAL 99 (expected 76)
  5. 100Evan BouchardEDM · 3.90 M$ · PAL 99 (expected 64)

Heaviest contracts

Lowest Value Rating among cap hits of $5M or more.

  1. 0Ryan StromeANA · 5.00 M$ · PAL 0 (expected 71)
  2. 1Josh AndersonMTL · 5.50 M$ · PAL 2 (expected 72)
  3. 2Cam FowlerANA · 6.50 M$ · PAL 7 (expected 74)
  4. 2Andrew CoppDET · 5.63 M$ · PAL 9 (expected 72)
  5. 3Brayden SchennSTL · 6.50 M$ · PAL 12 (expected 75)

The scale — PAL Rating

  • 90–100 Elite
  • 80–89 Excellent
  • 70–79 Very good
  • 60–69 Above average
  • 40–59 Around average
  • 20–39 Below average
  • 0–19 Very poor

The scale — Value Rating

  • 90–100 Exceptional value
  • 75–89 Very good contract
  • 55–74 Good value
  • 45–54 Fair value
  • 25–44 Poor return
  • 0–24 Very poor return
#Player
1Auston MatthewsTOR · F100100
2Sam ReinhartFLA · F100100
3Nathan MacKinnonCOL · F9997
4Connor McDavidEDM · F9999
5Zach HymanEDM · F9999
6Aleksander BarkovFLA · F9998
7Artemi PanarinNYR · F9894
8Kirill KaprizovMIN · F9897
9Filip ForsbergNSH · F9894
10William KarlssonVGK · F9899
11Nikita KucherovTBL · F9790
12David PastrnakBOS · F9791
13Seth JarvisCAR · F97100
14Matthew TkachukFLA · F9793
15Jason RobertsonDAL · F9692
16Roope HintzDAL · F9691
17Brady TkachukOTT · F9691
18John TavaresTOR · F9687
19Matt BoldyMIN · F9591
20Jack HughesNJD · F9589
21Conor GarlandVAN · F9594
22Noah CatesPHI · F9597
23Joel Eriksson EkMIN · F9593
24Elias PetterssonVAN · F9486
25Brayden PointTBL · F9486
26Mitch MarnerTOR · F9485
27Wyatt JohnstonDAL · F9499
28William NylanderTOR · F9384
29Sebastian AhoCAR · F9384
30Jesper BrattNJD · F9381
31Jake GuentzelCAR · F9388
32J.T. MillerVAN · F9281
33Jack EichelVGK · F9277
34Nico HischierNJD · F9281
35Chris KreiderNYR · F9283
36Dylan LarkinDET · F9178
37Brandon HagelTBL · F9195
38Pius SuterVAN · F9195
39Artturi LehkonenCOL · F9186
40Leon DraisaitlEDM · F9073
41Sidney CrosbyPIT · F9074
42Trevor MooreLAK · F9084
43Garnet HathawayPHI · F9091
44Anthony ManthaVGK · F8979
45Anthony CirelliTBL · F8976
46Quinton ByfieldLAK · F8996
47Stefan NoesenCAR · F8997
48Gabriel VilardiWPG · F8884
49Valeri NichushkinCOL · F8876
50Eetu LuostarinenFLA · F8892

PickALeague calculation from the play-by-play and on-ice shifts of every game (NHL data) and the season's cap hits.