PickALeague.com

The NHL's 10 best-value contracts of 2025-26

By Sébastien Ross · data 2025-26

Who gives the most for his salary? We compared each skater's performance (his PAL rating) with what a player paid the same is expected to deliver. Among the 316 skaters earning at least $3M who played 50+ games in 2025-26, here are the ones who beat expectations the most, and the ones furthest from them.

At the top: Shayne Gostisbehere (CAR). Paid $3.2M, he posts a PAL of 99 where 57 is expected at that salary: a gap of +42.

The 10 best values

  1. 1Carolina Hurricanes logoShayne Gostisbehere+42
  2. 2Philadelphia Flyers logoNoah Cates+38
  3. 3Florida Panthers logoEetu Luostarinen+37
  4. 4Nashville Predators logoLuke Evangelista+37
  5. 5Ottawa Senators logoDrake Batherson+32
  6. 6Pittsburgh Penguins logoRickard Rakell+32
  7. 7Vegas Golden Knights logoBrayden McNabb+32
  8. 8Ottawa Senators logoShane Pinto+31
  9. 9Edmonton Oilers logoZach Hyman+30
  10. 10Minnesota Wild logoMatt Boldy+29
Gap between the PAL earned and the PAL expected for that salary, in points out of 100.
PlayerCap hitPALGap
Shayne Gostisbehere CAR · D$3.2M99+42
Noah Cates PHI · F$4M97+38
Eetu Luostarinen FLA · F$3M91+37
Luke Evangelista NSH · F$3M91+37
Drake Batherson OTT · F$4.98M94+32
Rickard Rakell PIT · F$5M95+32
Brayden McNabb VGK · D$3.65M92+32
Shane Pinto OTT · F$3.75M90+31
Zach Hyman EDM · F$5.5M94+30
Matt Boldy MIN · F$7M98+29

The 10 worst values ($6M and up)

At the other end, among $6M+ contracts: Chandler Stephenson (SEA), paid $6.25M for a PAL of 0 against 68 expected. A negative gap doesn't mean a player is bad: it means his salary promised more that season.

  1. 1Seattle Kraken logoChandler Stephenson-68
  2. 2Winnipeg Jets logoNeal Pionk-62
  3. 3New York Islanders logoRyan Pulock-58
  4. 4Vancouver Canucks logoBrock Boeser-58
  5. 5Calgary Flames logoMatt Coronato-56
  6. 6Philadelphia Flyers logoTravis Konecny-56
  7. 7New York Islanders logoBrayden Schenn-55
  8. 8Washington Capitals logoAlex Ovechkin-53
  9. 9St. Louis Blues logoCam Fowler-53
  10. 10Anaheim Ducks logoMason McTavish-51
Gap between the PAL earned and the PAL expected for that salary, in points out of 100.
PlayerCap hitPALGap
Chandler Stephenson SEA · F$6.25M0-68
Neal Pionk WPG · D$7M7-62
Ryan Pulock NYI · D$6.15M10-58
Brock Boeser VAN · F$7.25M12-58
Matt Coronato CGY · F$6.5M13-56
Travis Konecny PHI · F$8.75M17-56
Brayden Schenn NYI · F$6.5M14-55
Alex Ovechkin WSH · F$9.5M22-53
Cam Fowler STL · D$6.5M16-53
Mason McTavish ANA · F$7M18-51

How we measured it