PickALeague.com

2023-24 NHL player ratings: skating, scoring, defense and 12 more

Fourteen ratings from 0 to 100 for every skater, all computed from data: the play-by-play and shifts of every game, NHL EDGE for skating, and PickALeague's analytics. None is assigned by hand. Each rating compares the player with others at the same position (centers, wingers, defensemen), over several seasons, and pulls small samples toward the average. OV describes the abilities a player has shown over several seasons; it is not a forecast: for next season, last season's performance (PAL) tells you as much. Hover a rating for its confidence.

PAL Rating, Value Rating and WAR remain separate measures →

The ratings

OV
Overall — Overall ability observed over several seasons, weighted by position
SK
Skating — Speed, bursts, distance and consistency (NHL EDGE)
ST
Strength — Physical strength proxy: contact absorbed, body mass
EN
Endurance — Workload handled: ice time, shifts
DU
Durability — Availability over several seasons
CK
Checking — Hits per 60 minutes, and their consistency
FG
Fighting — How often the player fights, not who wins
DI
Discipline — Penalties drawn minus taken, per 60 minutes
FO
Faceoffs — Faceoff win %, and volume
PA
Passing — Primary and secondary assists, creation
SC
Scoring — Goals, xG, finishing, high-danger chances
DF
Defense — Defensive RAPM, xG allowed, penalty kill
PS
Penalty shot — Shootouts and penalty shots
EX
Experience — Regular-season games, playoff games, NHL seasons

The scale95+ NHL elite90–94 Star85–89 High-end80–84 Very good70–79 Established NHL60–69 Depth0–59 Replacement or prospect

— : not enough data for a rating (no EDGE, too few faceoffs…). It is not a zero.

#Player
1Kirill KaprizovMIN · W · 269878699779666684—9196786771
2Connor McDavidEDM · C · 269898709785766097769894749787
3Cale MakarCOL · D · 249898379677586797—9497804979
4Auston MatthewsTOR · C · 269779799482746189818998798784
5Adam FoxNYR · D · 259761528981546289—9796946578
6David PastrnakBOS · W · 279784779387704786—9497608889
7Jason RobertsonDAL · W · 249662768688704778—9387929576
8Quinn HughesVAN · D · 239687519586415886—9887835877
9Aleksander BarkovFLA · C · 289678818676756681879580918789
10Nathan MacKinnonCOL · C · 289595649880646289639792655691
11Zach HymanEDM · W · 319574849385727569—8298698987
12Rasmus DahlinBUF · D · 239573769387795976—8995857662
13Sam ReinhartFLA · C · 279464798992707576638196989587
14Devon ToewsCOL · D · 299487458983685689—8583927682
15Miro HeiskanenDAL · D · 249490729178626490—9083807683
16Adrian KempeLAK · W · 279494698685787570—8586799080
17Leon DraisaitlEDM · C · 279385869689675769899693615689
18Jaccob SlavinCAR · D · 299378718286616092—8079957688
19Chris KreiderNYR · W · 329384768591775769618195727693
20Valeri NichushkinCOL · W · 289389789067747180—8389709086
21Nikita KucherovTBL · W · 309280539679615489—9885564792
22William KarlssonVGK · C · 309284708178666388868485905890
23Roope HintzDAL · C · 269294827984626280808690808482
24Drew DoughtyLAK · D · 339269739877735279—8386887696
25Jalen ChatfieldCAR · D · 279289865770737672—7686967669
26William NylanderTOR · W · 279177708994554780689393623985
27MacKenzie WeegarCGY · D · 299183698292858067—8290877678
28Jesper BrattNJD · W · 259192528489644787—9284694576
29Jake SandersonOTT · D · 219197798681607789—8081847650
30John TavaresTOR · C · 339168858287805874968595756593
31Filip ForsbergNSH · W · 299070728475807986—8794678990
32Elias PetterssonVAN · C · 249074618791775698709285818478
33Mitch MarnerTOR · W · 269067619578666480—9580819585
34Sebastian AhoCAR · C · 269085618783656274809089768786
35Evan BouchardEDM · D · 239081658593695478—9192787677
36Thomas HarleyDAL · D · 229084848061697382—8590786566
37Charlie McAvoyBOS · D · 259088838878787885—8887758584
38Nico HischierNJD · C · 249076718379626392888988756577
39Artemi PanarinNYR · W · 318969429489464780—9688689588
40Brayden PointTBL · C · 278997379084517485698897618687
41Roman JosiNSH · D · 338970659482607780—9698675593
42Dylan LarkinDET · C · 278984638678647788868988683676
43Jared McCannSEA · W · 278975648084667697668487785181
44Matt BoldyMIN · W · 228971799076607568708586859366
45Jack EichelVGK · C · 268992768868606991648786785682
46Mattias EkholmEDM · D · 338968778384777676—8788837693
47Hampus LindholmBOS · D · 298982868580637769—8274877690
48Jake GuentzelCAR · W · 288984668878676588—8992556285
49Mike MathesonMTL · D · 298994639776647878—8885706180
50J.T. MillerVAN · C · 308877798690868761879387698691
How each rating is calculated
OV — Overall
Ratings weighted by position (centers: SC, PA and DF 20%, SK 12%, FO 10%…; wingers: SC 28%, PA 22%, DF 18%, SK 12%…; defensemen: DF 30%, PA 22%, SK and SC 12%…). FG, PS and EX don't enter it, nor does salary.
SK — Skating
NHL EDGE: average top speed across seasons, bursts over 20 mph per 60, distance per 60, and the lowest seasonal top speed (consistency). No EDGE: no rating.
ST — Strength
A physical strength proxy, not a strength measurement: contact absorbed per 60 and body mass (mostly weight, a little height). Hits delivered are in CK. Ice time doesn't count: it reflects role, not strength. Being big isn't enough.
EN — Endurance
Ice time per game against the position, total ice time, average shift length, the lowest per-game ice time of recent seasons, and special-teams time. PAL doesn't enter it.
DU — Durability
The share of team games played, over five seasons, the most recent weighing most. Says nothing about a current injury.
CK — Checking
Hits per 60 minutes (70%), the lowest recent seasonal rate (20%) and volume (10%). Measures physical play, not defense.
FG — Fighting
Fights per 82 games over four seasons, with a strong prior: one fight doesn't make a fighter. Measures frequency, not outcome.
DI — Discipline
Net value of minor penalties (drawn minus taken, at the price of a penalty minute) per 60, penalties taken and drawn. Not raw PIM.
FO — Faceoffs
Faceoff %, pulled toward 50% with 200 average draws, and volume per 60. Under 150 faceoffs over the window: no rating.
PA — Passing
Primary assists per 60 (40%), secondary (20%), even-strength offensive creation (RAPM, 20%), power-play points (10%), consistency (10%).
SC — Scoring
Goals per 60 (25%), individual xG (20%), multi-season finishing (20%), high-danger chances (15%), shot quality (10%) and volume (10%).
DF — Defense
Defensive RAPM (35%, it accounts for teammates and opponents), relative xG against (20%), on-ice xG against (15%), penalty kill (10%), takeaways minus giveaways (10%), shot attempts against (5%), blocked shots (5%).
PS — Penalty shot
Shootouts (60%) and penalty shots (40%) over four seasons, very strongly pulled toward the average: with no attempt, the rating is an average player's, with zero confidence.
EX — Experience
A logarithmic scale, not a comparison: career regular-season games (65%, 1,200 = maximum), playoff games (25%, 200), NHL seasons (10%, 18). Going from 20 to 200 games counts far more than from 1,000 to 1,180.

For every rating: weighted seasons (50%, 25%, 15%, 10% by default), a prior toward the position average, the gap in standard deviations within the pool of regulars (400+ minutes), the percentile rank, then the rating: 50th percentile → 75, 90th → 87, 99.5th → 97. Confidence (0 to 1) reflects sample size; it never changes the rating.

PickALeague attribute engine, version 1.0. NHL and NHL EDGE data.