PickALeague.com
74LegendaryJohn Carlson headshot

John

Carlson

D · TBL · Offensive · Elite

PAL
94
WAR
2.0
Value
93
PTS
14

2025-26№ 21 / 325

John Carlson (Tampa Bay Lightning) stats and profile: offensive production, ice time, advanced stats, WAR and PAL rating.

John Carlson

#74DTampa Bay Lightning logoTampa Bay Lightning

HEIGHT : 191 cm · WEIGHT : 102 kg · SHOOTS : R

Born : January 9, 1990 · Natick, United States

Drafted : 2008 · WSH · round 1, pick #27

Contract : $8,500,000 · 2026-27 → 2027-28 · Standard Contract · UFA · Signing bonus $7,500,000NMC

NHL record

Year Team GPGAPTSPIM
2026-27Tampa Bay Lightning1755102
2025-26Anaheim Ducks16410146
2025-26Washington Capitals5510364626
2024-25Washington Capitals795465122
2023-24Washington Capitals8210425240
2022-23Washington Capitals409202912
2021-22Washington Capitals7817547120
2020-21Washington Capitals5210344412
2019-20Washington Capitals6915607526
2018-19Washington Capitals8013577034
2017-18Washington Capitals8215536832
2016-17Washington Capitals729283710
2015-16Washington Capitals568313914
2014-15Washington Capitals8212435528
2013-14Washington Capitals8210273722
2012-13Washington Capitals486162218
2011-12Washington Capitals829233222
2010-11Washington Capitals827303744
2009-10Washington Capitals221568
NHL totals1175175620795398

Playoffs

Year Team GPGAPTSPIM
2025-26Anaheim Ducks120664
2024-25Washington Capitals101232
2023-24Washington Capitals41122
2021-22Washington Capitals61452
2020-21Washington Capitals50226
2019-20Washington Capitals50662
2018-19Washington Capitals70556
2017-18Washington Capitals24515208
2016-17Washington Capitals132244
2015-16Washington Capitals1257124
2014-15Washington Capitals141564
2012-13Washington Capitals70114
2011-12Washington Capitals142358
2010-11Washington Capitals92134
2009-10Washington Capitals71340
Playoff totals14921638460

Honours

  • 🏆 Stanley Cuponce · 2017-18

John Carlson: our analysis

2025-26 season: 16 GP, 4 G, 10 A, 14 PTS, -2 +/-, 24:11 TOI. WAR 2.0 (21st of 325) · PAL 94, elite.

In 2025-26, John Carlson, 36, posts a PAL Rating of 94 out of 100 (elite), and his WAR of 2.0 ranks 21st among 325 regulars, in the top quarter.

His strengths: creation (97, among the best in the league), offense (96, among the best in the league) and power play (96, among the best in the league). On the other hand, penalty kill (4, among the weakest in the league) and discipline (32, below average) hold him back.

Breaking down his WAR (goals above average), his biggest contribution: EV offense (+9.0); his biggest cost: penalties (-1.5).

A season in line with 2024-25 (PAL of 92); his WAR went from 0.9 to 2.0.

Contract-wise, his Value score of 93 (exceptional value) weighs his output against what he costs: 50 is what that salary should buy.

John Carlson's story

Growing up first in Marlborough before his family moved to New Jersey, Carlson learned to skate and rose through local youth ranks with the New Jersey Rockets. He spent his final junior season with the Indiana Ice in the USHL, a campaign that brought him significant attention from NHL scouts and opened the door to major junior hockey in London, Ontario.

Drafted in the first round, 27th overall, by the Washington Capitals in 2008, Carlson signed an entry-level contract during his first season with the London Knights. He made his professional debut with the Hershey Bears in the Calder Cup playoffs and was part of Hershey's championship runs in 2009 and again in 2010 before establishing himself full-time in the NHL.

Carlson played his first NHL game on 20 November 2009 and scored his first NHL goal on 25 March 2010. Over the following years he became a mainstay on Washington's blue line, piling up minutes, power-play points and durable seasons. The high point of his time with the Capitals came in 2018 when he helped the club lift the Stanley Cup, finishing the playoffs as the highest-scoring defenseman. Contract extensions followed — a six-year deal in 2012 and an eight-year extension in June 2018 — and he was named an alternate captain at the start of the 2019–20 season.

Internationally, Carlson represented the United States at the 2010 World Junior Championship and was named to the U.S. Olympic team in 2014. His long tenure in Washington ended in early 2026 when he was traded to the Anaheim Ducks on 6 March.

On the ice, Carlson is best known as an offensively inclined defenseman who eats up ice time and quarterbacks the power play. He consistently contributes assists and joins the rush, while also being relied upon to match up against opponents' top forwards and take on heavy minutes in all situations.

John Carlson warming up with the Capitals on February 5, 2026
John Carlson warming up for the Washington Capitals before a game against the Nashville Predators, February 5, 2026.Photo: The Kip · CC BY-SA 4.0
John Carlson (74) with the puck against the Stars, March 20, 2022
John Carlson with the puck in the third period against the Dallas Stars at Capital One Arena, March 20, 2022.Photo: All-Pro Reels from District of Columbia, USA · CC BY-SA 2.0
John Carlson in action on March 20, 2022
John Carlson during the Dallas Stars at Washington Capitals game, March 20, 2022.Photo: All-Pro Reels from District of Columbia, USA · CC BY-SA 2.0
John Carlson skating with the puck against the Islanders, March 15, 2022
John Carlson skating with the puck in the third period against the New York Islanders at Capital One Arena, March 15, 2022.Photo: All-Pro Reels from District of Columbia, USA · CC BY-SA 2.0
John Carlson (74) with the puck against the Blue Jackets, February 8, 2022
John Carlson with the puck in the third period against the Columbus Blue Jackets at Capital One Arena, February 8, 2022.Photo: All-Pro Reels from District of Columbia, USA · CC BY-SA 2.0
John Carlson (74) lined up for a faceoff with teammates, February 8, 2022
John Carlson lined up for a faceoff with Garnet Hathaway and Carl Hagelin against the Columbus Blue Jackets, February 8, 2022.Photo: All-Pro Reels from District of Columbia, USA · CC BY-SA 2.0

Facts drawn from Wikipédia, told in our own words.

Advanced stats

TOI/GP
19:18
PP TOI/GP
3:56
SH TOI/GP
0:03
Pts/GP
0.59
EV points
7
Hits
13
Blocks
15
Takeaways
1
Corsi % (SAT)
56.2 %
Off. zone starts
44.2 %

Stats and photos: NHL (NHL.com)

2026-27 projection

Projected points

54between 36 and 70 (80% range)

Goals
17
Assists
37
Games
79

So far: 10 pts in 17 games. The team has played 17 of 84 games. Projected pace: 0.72 pts per game (last season: 0.85).

Three straight seasons of growth. Since 2018, of 97 players in that spot, 23 kept improving the next season; on average, their pace fell back to 90% of their best season.

The projection follows last season's pace. Tested on 2,265 player seasons (2022-23 to 2025-26): average miss of 9 points over 82 games; for players at 0.9 points per game and up, it ran 5 points high on average.

Trend

Slightly up

  • Points per game: 0.63 in 23-24, 0.85 in 25-26
  • PAL Rating: 92 → 94

Outlook, age included

→ StableAge 36: the age when production usually declines

This is only a projection. It knows nothing about injuries, trades or role changes; one player in five finishes outside the range.

Player ratings, 2025-26

All ratings →

Fourteen ratings from 0 to 100 drawn from data, never by hand: 75 = established NHL player, 95+ = elite.

OV · OverallConfidence 86 %

79

Established NHL

SK
Skating
70
Confidence 73 %
ST
Strength
73
Confidence 89 %
EN
Endurance
89
Confidence 80 %
DU
Durability
79
Confidence 77 %
CK
Checking
62
Confidence 89 %
FG
Fighting
62
Confidence 63 %
DI
Discipline
77
Confidence 89 %
FO
Faceoffs
—
PA
Passing
90
Confidence 86 %
SC
Scoring
88
Confidence 86 %
DF
Defense
60
Confidence 84 %
PS
Penalty shot
61
Confidence 33 %
EX
Experience
98
Confidence 100 %
Why these ratings?

SK — Skating70

  • Top speed (35 %)35.6 · 78
  • Bursts > 20 mph /60 (30 %)1.507 · 69
  • Distance /60 (20 %)13.7 · 61
  • Speed consistency (15 %)34.2 · 70

ST — Strength73

  • Contact absorbed /60 (50 %)3.199 · 57
  • Body mass (50 %)1.357 · 86

EN — Endurance89

  • Ice time per game (45 %)22 · 88
  • Total ice time (20 %)1,572 · 80
  • Shift length (15 %)53.4 · 89
  • Lowest recent ice time per game (15 %)21.2 · 89
  • Special-teams time per game (5 %)4.763 · 93

DU — Durability79

  • Share of games played (100 %)0.842 · 79

CK — Checking62

  • Hits /60 (70 %)1.772 · 61
  • Lowest seasonal rate (20 %)1.406 · 62
  • Season volume (10 %)3.296 · 64

FG — Fighting62

  • Fights per 82 games (100 %)0.681 · 62

DI — Discipline77

  • Net penalty value /60 (50 %)-0.033 · 77
  • Penalties taken /60 (30 %)0.526 · 80
  • Penalties drawn /60 (20 %)0.335 · 69

PA — Passing90

  • Primary assists /60 (40 %)0.716 · 89
  • Secondary assists /60 (20 %)0.753 · 90
  • Offensive creation (RAPM) (20 %)0.319 · 96
  • Power-play points /60 (10 %)4.321 · 81
  • Assist consistency (10 %)0.429 · 88

SC — Scoring88

  • Goals /60 (25 %)0.372 · 87
  • Individual xG /60 (20 %)0.362 · 90
  • Finishing (goals − xG per shot) (20 %)-0.004 · 65
  • High-danger chances /60 (15 %)0.27 · 90
  • xG per shot (10 %)0.038 · 89
  • Shot attempts /60 (10 %)13 · 87

DF — Defense60

  • RAPM defense /60 (35 %)-0.061 · 64
  • Relative xG against (20 %)0.079 · 68
  • On-ice xG against /60 (15 %)2.783 · 62
  • Penalty kill /60 (10 %)-0.35 · 49
  • Takeaways − giveaways /60 (10 %)-2.196 · 69
  • Shot attempts against /60 (5 %)59 · 70
  • Blocked shots /60 (5 %)4.616 · 77

PS — Penalty shot61

  • Shootouts (60 %)30.7 · 59
  • Penalty shots (40 %)26.7 · 76

EX — Experience98

  • Career regular-season games (65 %)100
  • Career playoff games (25 %)94
  • NHL seasons (10 %)98

OV — Overall79

  • DF · Defense (30 %)60
  • PA · Passing (22 %)90
  • SK · Skating (12 %)70
  • SC · Scoring (12 %)88
  • EN · Endurance (9 %)89
  • ST · Strength (6 %)73
  • DI · Discipline (5 %)77
  • CK · Checking (4 %)62
Season by season
SeasonOVSKSCDF
2025-2679708860
2024-2577688258
2023-2476658757
2022-2376649259

The bars show confidence (sample size), not player quality. — : not enough data, not a zero. Engine version 1.0.

WAR and PAL ratings, 2025-26

How we rate →

PAL Rating scores performance from 0 to 100 against players at the same position (50 = average player), starting from the player's strength, offensive or defensive. Value Rating compares that performance with what the player costs: 50 means paid what the play is worth.

ProfileOffensiveValue comes mostly from offense

Offense
98
Defense
37
See full details
Offense
96
Creation
97
Shooting
93
Possession
90
Defense
32
Discipline
32
Power play
96
Penalty kill
4

From 0 to 100; 50 is the average player at the same position, adjusted for ice time.

Season by season
SeasonTeamWARPALValue
2025-26ANA2.09493
2024-25WSH0.99279
2023-24WSH1.18357
2022-23WSH0.69384

Hockey IQ, 2025-26

Rankings and method →

The quality of the player's decisions with and against the puck at 5-on-5, against regulars at the same position (50 = average). PAL measures output; IQ measures how the player plays.

Overall IQ

92/ 100

Elite
better than 92% of defensemen, offense and defense combined

Offensive IQ

86/ 100

Very good
passing, shots, puck

Defensive IQ

90/ 100

Elite
takeaways, discipline, own zone

Why 92, higher than both scores? Overall IQ isn't an average, it's a rank: 17 of 225 defensemen. Few players are good at both ends at once; being so puts John Carlson ahead of almost everyone else.

See full details

Offense

Playmaking passes
96
Shot selection
93
Penalties drawn
22
Puck management
23

Defense

Takeaways
99
Discipline
35
Safe zone exits
58

Percentiles: 80 means better than 80% of regulars at the same position. Play without the puck (positioning, coverage) isn't measured: the NHL doesn't publish that data.

Season by season
SeasonTeamIQOff.Def.
2025-26ANA928690
2024-25WSH969490
2023-24WSH857875
2022-23WSH908981

Wins added to the team, compared with a replacement-level player called up from the AHL.

2.0

wins above replacement

0.7 to 3.6 — 90% interval

21 of 325 defensemen

+10.6 goals above replacement

Full leaderboard →
See full details
EV offense
+9.0
EV defense
-1.2
Power play
+1.0
Penalty kill
-1.4
Shooting
+1.5
Penalties
-1.5
Average → replacement
+3.3

In goals.

Season by season
SeasonTeamGPWARRank
2025-26ANA712.021/325
2024-25WSH770.955/314
2023-24WSH821.142/316
2022-23WSH400.666/334

Player tracking (NHL EDGE)

League EDGE leaderboards →

Speed, shot power, distance covered, time by zone: measured by chips in the puck and shoulder pads. 90th percentile = better than 90% of players.

Season
Hardest shot
152.8 km/h90th percentileleague avg. 139.7 km/h
Top skating speed
34.2 km/h55th percentileleague avg. 34.0 km/h
Bursts over 20 mph, season
329th percentileleague avg. 8
Offensive zone time
46.4 %95th percentileleague avg. 42.4 %
See full details
Total distance, season
69.5 km58th percentileleague avg. 56.1 km
Distance, single-game high
5.38 km65th percentileleague avg. 4.98 km
Offensive zone at 5v5
43.2 %67th percentileleague avg. 42.8 %
Neutral zone time
18.3 %60th percentileleague avg. 16.9 %
Defensive zone time
35.3 %95th percentileleague avg. 40.8 %

Shooting

Shots on goalGoalsShooting %
All3895th percentile599th percentile13.2 %91st percentile
High danger7100th percentile198th percentile14.3 %63rd percentile
Mid range1093rd percentile297th percentile20.0 %77th percentile
Long range1792nd percentile299th percentile11.8 %93rd percentile

Shots on goal by zone

Neutral zone : 0 · 82th percentileOutside left : 1 · 76th percentileOutside right : 3 · 95th percentileLeft point : 1 · 53th percentileRight point : 8 · 93th percentileCenter point : 8 · 95th percentileLeft circle : 1 · 66th percentileRight circle : 3 · 92th percentileHigh slot : 6 · 98th percentileLeft of the net : 0 · 82th percentileRight of the net : 0 · 84th percentileLow slot : 7 · 100th percentileCrease : 0 · 92th percentileLeft corner : 0 · 98th percentileBehind the net : 0 · 95th percentileRight corner : 0 · 98th percentile0131881360070000
Beyond the red line : 0

2026-2027 regular season. Measured by puck and player tracking chips; the percentile ranks the player within the league.

Game log, 2026-27

DateOpponentGAPTS+/-
Nov 8@Winnipeg Jets logoWPG0000
Nov 7@Minnesota Wild logoMIN022+1
Nov 5vsChicago Blackhawks logoCHI000-1
Nov 3vsDetroit Red Wings logoDET0000
Oct 31@Nashville Predators logoNSH112+2
Oct 29vsWinnipeg Jets logoWPG101+2
Oct 24@Utah Mammoth logoUTA000-1
Oct 23@Colorado Avalanche logoCOL000-2
Oct 20@Vegas Golden Knights logoVGK101+3
Oct 17vsVancouver Canucks logoVAN0000

John Carlson: frequently asked questions

How many goals does John Carlson have in 2026-27?

John Carlson has 5 goals and 10 points (5 assists) in 17 games in 2026-27.

How old is John Carlson?

John Carlson is 36 years old: he was born on January 10, 1990.

How tall is John Carlson, and how much does he weigh?

John Carlson is 6'3" (191 cm) and weighs 225 lb (102 kg).

Where is John Carlson from?

United States: John Carlson was born in Natick, Massachusetts, United States.

What team does John Carlson play for?

John Carlson plays for the Tampa Bay Lightning in the NHL, at D, wearing number 74.

Is John Carlson injured?

No: John Carlson is not on the latest NHL injury report. This answer is updated throughout the season.

How good is John Carlson?

John Carlson produced 2.0 wins above replacement (WAR) in 2025-26, 21st of 325 players at his position in the NHL. His PAL rating is 94 out of 100: elite for his position.

How much does John Carlson make?

John Carlson earns $8.0M for the 2025-26 season. His Value Rating is 93 out of 100 (exceptional value): it measures the on-field return for that salary, compared with players at his position.

When does John Carlson's contract end?

John Carlson's contract runs through the 2027-28 season; he will then be an unrestricted free agent. It includes a NMC clause.

Is John Carlson overpaid?

No, he gives more than he costs. His Value rating is 93 out of 100 (exceptional value), where 50 is the output expected for his salary, compared with players at his position.

Is John Carlson a top-10 player at his position?

No: by WAR, he ranks 21st of 325 players at his position in the NHL in 2025-26. Our comparison tool puts him side by side with any other player.

Is John Carlson getting better?

He is holding steady: his PAL rating went from 92 in 2024-25 to 94 in 2025-26 (out of 100, 50 = average player at his position).

How has John Carlson played lately?

Over his last 10 games, John Carlson has 6 points (3 goals, 3 assists).

What are John Carlson's career stats?

Over his NHL career, John Carlson has 1,175 games, 175 goals, 620 assists and 795 points. His best season: 2019-20, with 75 points in 69 games.

Where was John Carlson drafted?

John Carlson was drafted 27th overall (round 1) by Washington Capitals in 2008.

Is John Carlson better at home or on the road?

No real difference: in 2026-27, he averages 0.63 points per game at home (5 in 8 games) and 0.56 on the road (5 in 9 games).

How does John Carlson perform in the playoffs?

In the playoffs, John Carlson has 149 games and 84 points in his career. His pace (0.56 points per game) is lower than his regular-season pace (0.68).

Which player is most similar to John Carlson?

Darren Raddysh: he is the player at his position whose PAL profile (the 0-to-100 dimensions) is closest to his in 2025-26.

Darren Raddysh's page →

Is John Carlson a good fantasy pick?

A useful depth pick: our projection has him at 54 points in 2026-27, or 0.68 points per game.

Does John Carlson have siblings?

Yes: his brother Andrew Carlson (played junior hockey for the New Jersey Rockets).

Is John Carlson married?

Yes, married to Gina Nucci (2014).

What is John Carlson's nationality?

John Carlson is American. Internationally: United States — gold medal at the 2010 World Junior Championships (scored overtime winner in the final); played at the 2014 Winter Olympics (4th place); represented the U.S. at junior tournaments in 2007 (Ivan Hlinka, World Junior A Challenge); named to the 2016 World Cup of Hockey team.

What awards has John Carlson won?

Atlantic Junior Hockey League Offensive Defenseman of the Year (2006–07) ; USHL Second All‑Star Team and All‑Rookie Team (2007–08) ; OHL Rookie of the Month (December 2008) ; Named to the OHL Second All‑Star Team, OHL First All‑Rookie Team and CHL All‑Rookie Team (2008–09) ; AHL All‑Rookie Team (2010) ; NHL First All‑Star Team (2019–20) ; NHL First Star of the Month (October 2019).

How many championships has John Carlson won?

3: Calder Cup with the Hershey Bears (2009); Calder Cup with the Hershey Bears (2010); Stanley Cup with the Washington Capitals (2018).

Where did John Carlson play before turning pro?

New Jersey Rockets (Atlantic Youth Hockey League, youth); Indiana Ice (USHL, 2007–08 season); London Knights (OHL, 2008–09 season).

How many points is John Carlson projected to score in 2026-27?

Our projection has him at 54 points in 79 games in 2026-27 (36 to 70 points, 80% interval), based on his recent seasons, age and role.

See also: his Tampa Bay Lightning teammates

Full roster →

NHL.com ↗ · Stats and photos: NHL (NHL.com)