PickALeague.com
35BaseColin Holderman headshot

Colin

Holderman

P · CLE · Above average

PAL
63
WAR
0.8
Value
66
ERA
2.73

2026№ 58 / 263

Colin Holderman

#35PCleveland Guardians logoCleveland Guardians

Biography

Height
6' 6"
Weight
104 kg
Bats
R
Throws
R
MLB debut
May 15, 2022
Born
October 8, 1995 (31)
Birthplace
Bourbonnais, IL, USA
Draft
2016

Career history

  • Cleveland Guardians · 2026 (1 season)
  • Pittsburgh Pirates · 2022 – 2025 (4 seasons)
  • New York Mets · 2022 (1 season)

MLB record

YearTeamPJVDMPMMJRBWHIP
2026Cleveland Guardians54642.7352.2501.04
2025Pittsburgh Pirates24027.0125.2181.95
2024Pittsburgh Pirates55363.1651.1561.31
2023Pittsburgh Pirates58033.8656.0581.34
202224503.8128.1241.20
2022Pittsburgh Pirates9106.7510.261.50
2022New York Mets15402.0417.2181.02
Career totals21514153.79214.02061.31

Colin Holderman: our analysis

2026 season: 54 G, 52.7 IP, 6 W, 4 L, 50 SO, 1.04 WHIP. WAR 0.8 (58th of 263) · PAL 63, above average.

In 2026, Colin Holderman, 31, posts a PAL Rating of 63 out of 100 (above average), and his WAR of 0.8 ranks 58th among 263 regulars, in the top quarter.

His strengths: velocity (80, well above average) and run prevention (72, above average). On the other hand, contact allowed (27, below average) holds him back.

A clear step forward: his PAL went from 5 in 2025 to 63; his WAR went from -0.4 to 0.8.

Contract-wise, his Value score of 66 (good value) weighs his output against what he costs: 50 is what that salary should buy.

Colin Holderman's story

Raised in Bradley, Illinois, Colin Holderman worked his way from local youth ball to high school at Bradley-Bourbonnais, graduating in 2014 before beginning a collegiate career at Southern Illinois. After one season with the Salukis he transferred to Heartland Community College, where his performance earned him National Junior College Athletic Association Division II Player of the Year honours and a commitment to Mississippi State—an arrangement he ultimately set aside when the pros came calling.

The New York Mets selected Holderman in the ninth round (280th overall) of the 2016 MLB draft and he signed instead of transferring. He started in the low minors at Kingsport and climbed through the organization, spending time with Columbia, Brooklyn and St. Lucie in 2019; that year he posted a combined 4–2 record, a 3.53 ERA and 49 strikeouts in 66 1/3 innings across three affiliates.

Tommy John surgery cost him the 2018 season, and the cancelled minor-league season in 2020 cost another year of game action. Back in 2021, he settled into a late-inning role with Double-A Binghamton, working as the team’s closer and finishing with a 3.38 ERA. After a rough Arizona Fall League stint, the Mets did not add him to their 40-man roster, but they promoted him to the majors on May 15, 2022; he made his big-league debut that afternoon with a scoreless ninth inning against the Seattle Mariners.

New York traded Holderman to the Pittsburgh Pirates on July 22, 2022, for Daniel Vogelbach; Pittsburgh optioned him briefly to Triple-A Indianapolis before promoting him on August 2. He appeared nine times for the Pirates in 2022. On May 4, 2023, Holderman recorded an immaculate inning versus the Tampa Bay Rays, striking out Taylor Walls, Luke Raley and Christian Bethancourt in order. He finished 2023 with 58 relief appearances, 58 strikeouts, two saves and a 3.86 ERA in 56 innings. The following seasons saw him make 55 appearances in 2024 (3.16 ERA) and 24 in 2025 (7.01 ERA).

Designated for assignment on November 18, 2025 and non-tendered on November 21, Holderman reached free agency and signed a one-year, $1.5 million contract with the Cleveland Guardians on December 11, 2025. His résumé shows a reliever who advanced through the minors, overcame major surgery, and settled into short-leverage roles at the big-league level.

Colin Holderman in 2025, pitcher
Colin Holderman, image titled “Colin Holderman 2025,” dated August 28, 2025.Photo: Johnmaxmena2 · CC BY 4.0
Colin Holderman and Stephen Nogosek on USS Bataan flight deck in 2022
Colin Holderman and Stephen Nogosek aboard USS Bataan during Fleet Week New York, May 28, 2022.Photo: U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 3rd Class Preston Cash · Public domain
Cropped close-up of Colin Holderman on USS Bataan flight deck
Cropped close-up of Colin Holderman on USS Bataan during Fleet Week New York, May 28, 2022.Photo: U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 3rd Class Preston Cash · Public domain

Facts drawn from Wikipédia, told in our own words.

Type
Arbitration
Length
1 yr · 2027–2027
Total value
0.0 M$
AAV
—

Advanced stats, 2026 Relief pitcher

MLB stats →

ERA

2.73

FIP

3.16

xFIP

4.14

ERA-

66

WHIP

1.04

K%

22.5 %

BB%

9.0 %

Strikeouts

50

Innings

52.7

Wins

6

Stats: MLB (statsapi) and Baseball Savant.

2027 projection

MLB trends →

Projected WAR

0.6

80% of cases: -0.2 to 1.4

Strikeouts

36

2026 WAR

0.8

This season's pace, over the average of the last two workloads, adjusted for next year's age.

Trend

↑ Slightly up (+11)

  • 20230.9 WAR · 1.0 per full season
  • 20240.2 WAR · 0.3 per full season
  • 2025-0.4 WAR · -1.0 per full season
  • 20260.8 WAR · 1.0 per full season

Outlook, age included

+11 · 30 y.o. · prime years

It is only a projection. It knows nothing about injuries, trades or role changes.

Player ratings, 2026

All ratings →

Ratings from 0 to 100 drawn from Statcast, never by hand: 75 = established regular, 95+ = elite.

OV · Overall

69

Depth

VEL
Velocity
85
STF
Stuff
71
CTL
Control
72
CNT
Contact allowed
64
STA
Stamina
—
DUR
Durability
78
EX
Experience
61
Why these ratings?
  • VEL — Velocity : Fastball velocity
  • STF — Stuff : Strikeouts, K − BB
  • CTL — Control : Walks avoided
  • CNT — Contact allowed : xwOBA, barrels and hard-hit balls allowed
  • STA — Stamina : Innings per start and innings pitched
  • DUR — Durability : Games played over several seasons
  • EX — Experience : Seasons in the majors

WAR and PAL Rating, 2026

How we rate →

WAR is fWAR (FanGraphs' version, distributed through MLB's API): wins added above a replacement player. PAL Rating scores performance from 0 to 100 against regulars in the same role (50 = median).

PAL: dimensions

Run prevention72
Stuff48
Command53
Contact allowed27
Velocity80

A pitcher's WAR

Computed by MLB from FIP (strikeouts, walks, home runs). FIP: 3.16 · RA9-WAR: 1.1

MLB's tracking of every ball, 2026 season. The percentile ranks the player among regulars in the role: 90th means better than 90% of them.

Fastball

97.0 mi/h

80th percentile

K%

22.5 %

45th percentile

BB%

9.0 %

53th percentile

xERA

3.87

52th percentile

xwOBA allowed

.303

52th percentile

Barrels allowed

7.7 %

35th percentile

Season by season
SeasonTeamWARPALOVFastballK%BB%xERAxwOBA allowed
2026CLE0.8636997.022.59.03.87.303
2025PIT-0.456397.014.412.85.73.364
2024PIT0.2447297.225.111.24.08.316
2023PIT0.9707897.824.28.33.61.294
2022PIT0.3377096.220.311.93.52.295

Game log, 2026

DateOpponentIPHERBBSOERA
Sep 3vs TOR0.110102.73
Aug 29vs KC0.143002.75
Aug 25@ LAA1.000012.25
Aug 24@ LAA1.010032.29
Aug 21@ COL1.010202.34
Aug 15vs SD0.200002.39
Aug 14vs SD0.222002.42
Aug 12@ DET1.100112.08
Aug 9@ CWS1.200122.14
Aug 8@ CWS0.023002.22

Colin Holderman: frequently asked questions

What is Colin Holderman's record in 2026?

Colin Holderman is 6-4 in 2026, with a 2.73 ERA and 50 strikeouts in 52.7 innings, 1 save.

How old is Colin Holderman?

Colin Holderman is 31 years old: he was born on October 8, 1995.

How tall is Colin Holderman, and how much does he weigh?

Colin Holderman is 6'6" (198 cm) and weighs 229 lb (104 kg).

Where is Colin Holderman from?

United States: Colin Holderman was born in Bourbonnais, IL, United States.

What team does Colin Holderman play for?

Colin Holderman plays for the Cleveland Guardians in the MLB, at P, wearing number 35.

How good is Colin Holderman?

Colin Holderman produced 0.8 wins above replacement (WAR) in 2026, 67th of 263 players at his position in the MLB. His PAL rating is 63 out of 100: above average for his position.

How much does Colin Holderman make?

Colin Holderman earns $1.5M for the 2026 season. His Value Rating is 66 out of 100 (good value): it measures the on-field return for that salary, compared with players at his position.

Is Colin Holderman overpaid?

No, he gives more than he costs. His Value rating is 66 out of 100 (good value), where 50 is the output expected for his salary, compared with players at his position.

Is Colin Holderman a top-10 player at his position?

No: by WAR, he ranks 67th of 263 players at his position in the MLB in 2026. Our comparison tool puts him side by side with any other player.

Is Colin Holderman getting better?

Yes: his PAL rating went from 5 in 2025 to 63 in 2026 (out of 100, 50 = average player at his position).

Where was Colin Holderman drafted?

Colin Holderman: 2016.

Which player is most similar to Colin Holderman?

Wilber Dotel: he is the player at his position whose PAL profile (the 0-to-100 dimensions) is closest to his in 2026.

Wilber Dotel's page →

Is Colin Holderman married?

Yes, married to Casey Spence in 2020.

What is Colin Holderman's nationality?

Colin Holderman is American.

What awards has Colin Holderman won?

Named the National Junior College Athletic Association's Division II Baseball Player of the Year.

Where did Colin Holderman play before turning pro?

Graduated Bradley‑Bourbonnais Community High School (2014); one year at Southern Illinois University with the Southern Illinois Salukis; one year at Heartland Community College (named NJCAA Division II Player of the Year); committed to transfer to Mississippi State before signing after the draft.

What is Colin Holderman's projection for 2027?

Our projection has him at 0.6 WAR in 2027, based on his weighted recent seasons and age.

See also: his Cleveland Guardians teammates

Full roster →