PickALeague.com

2026 MLB PAL Rating and Value Rating: performance and contract value

Two scores from 0 to 100. PAL Rating measures the season's performance against regulars in the same role (hitters, starters, relievers): 50 is the median regular. Salary never enters it. Value Rating answers a different question: for what the player costs, does the return come in more or less than expected?

WAR, in wins →Payrolls →

Top hitterPete Crow-Armstrong headshot100PAL100ValuePete Crow-ArmstrongCHC · EliteTop starterJacob Misiorowski headshot100PAL100ValueJacob MisiorowskiMIL · EliteTop relieverMason Miller headshot100PAL100ValueMason MillerSD · Elite

Best contracts

Highest Value Rating among players rated 70 or more.

  1. 100Pete Crow-ArmstrongCHC · 0.89 M$ · WAR paid 0.1, produced 10.6
  2. 100Jacob MisiorowskiMIL · 0.79 M$ · WAR paid 0.1, produced 6.6
  3. 100Mason MillerSD · 4.00 M$ · WAR paid 0.4, produced 3.7
  4. 100Elly De La CruzCIN · 0.80 M$ · WAR paid 0.1, produced 6.4
  5. 100Louis VarlandTOR · 0.82 M$ · WAR paid 0.1, produced 3.1

Heaviest contracts

Lowest Value Rating among contracts of $15M or more per year.

  1. 0Kyle TuckerLAD · 57.20 M$ · WAR paid 5.0, produced 0.9
  2. 0Kodai SengaNYM · 15.00 M$ · WAR paid 1.3, produced -0.6
  3. 1Jameson TaillonTOR · 18.00 M$ · WAR paid 1.6, produced -1.0
  4. 2Marcus SemienNYM · 24.00 M$ · WAR paid 2.1, produced -0.5
  5. 3Vladimir Guerrero Jr.TOR · 35.71 M$ · WAR paid 3.1, produced 1.0

The scale — PAL Rating

  • 90–100 Elite
  • 80–89 Excellent
  • 70–79 Very good
  • 60–69 Above average
  • 40–59 Around average
  • 20–39 Below average
  • 0–19 Very poor

The scale — Value Rating

  • 90–100 Exceptional value
  • 75–89 Very good contract
  • 55–74 Good value
  • 45–54 Fair value
  • 25–44 Poor return
  • 0–24 Very poor return
#Player
1Pete Crow-ArmstrongCHC · CF · 241001000.910.699975298100
2Yordan AlvarezHOU · DH · 29999819.26.81009999417
3Bobby Witt Jr.KC · SS · 26999726.37.086718310099
4Elly De La CruzCIN · SS · 24991000.86.49697408883
5Pete AlonsoBAL · 1B · 31987031.05.0999963443
6Juan SotoNYM · LF · 2798751.03.199951003018
7James WoodWSH · RF · 2398920.84.09899856610
8Fernando Tatis Jr.SD · RF · 27978624.35.49385669373
9Brice TurangMIL · 2B · 2697994.25.98662747996
10Willson ContrerasBOS · 1B · 34966721.34.09889502646
11Shohei OhtaniLAD · TWP · 31961846.13.79795746220
12Gabriel MorenoAZ · C · 2696982.55.49550932483
13Miguel VargasCWS · 3B · 2695980.85.39487988320
14Jackson ChourioMIL · LF · 22959010.34.68786308485
15Ben RiceNYY · DH · 2795940.84.29898723410
16Brandon LowePIT · 2B · 31949211.54.97892173995
17Nick KurtzATH · 1B · 2394740.82.69595813827
18Matt OlsonATL · 1B · 32936721.04.08396341986
19Oneil CruzPIT · CF · 2793823.33.39093179449
20Corbin CarrollAZ · RF · 25938213.94.27586659782
21Jake BauersMIL · 1B · 3092872.73.6969289579
22Seiya SuzukiCHC · RF · 31928217.04.59172713579
23JJ WetherholtSTL · 2B · 2392960.84.65440827699
24Randy ArozarenaSEA · LF · 31919415.75.59773627217
25Junior CamineroTB · 3B · 2291980.85.3969685257
26Alex BregmanCHC · 3B · 32907930.95.58458943386
27Andy PagesLAD · CF · 2590960.84.58065536191
28Munetaka MurakamiCWS · 1B · 26905217.02.986100593238
29Kyle SchwarberPHI · DH · 33892830.02.99398621025
30Michael Harris IIATL · CF · 2589909.04.5797585493
31Otto LopezMIA · SS · 2789990.85.97225619596
32Max MuncyLAD · 3B · 35888212.34.18790605150
33Byron BuxtonMIN · CF · 32885014.32.68394197855
34Bryce HarperPHI · 1B · 33874425.43.3957897308
35Rafael DeversSF · 1B · 29874029.73.59296472628
36Ty FranceSD · 1B · 3187872.03.6927831278
37Mike TroutLAA · CF · 34862635.53.39380955816
38Geraldo PerdomoAZ · SS · 26869311.35.06910994997
39Kevin McGonigleDET · SS · 2186990.85.48935987543
40Mookie BettsLAD · SS · 33855325.63.77271913688
41Chase DeLauterCLE · RF · 2485870.83.58757924753
42Griffin ConineMIA · RF · 2884590.81.89093274634
43Alec BurlesonSTL · 1B · 2784813.33.28984602241
44Dominic CanzoneSEA · DH · 2884780.82.89287542934
45Garrett MitchellMIL · CF · 2783820.93.17769228772
46Drake BaldwinATL · C · 2583850.83.39181461740
47Jackson MerrillSD · CF · 23838015.04.2608399584
48Luis García Jr.NYY · 1B · 2682646.92.68193212060
49Riley GreeneDET · LF · 2582785.03.29480562714
50Cody BellingerNYY · LF · 30811744.83.57346875484
How it's calculated

In MLB, salary follows service time (pre-arbitration, arbitration), not performance: a young player at the minimum can be a star. Value Rating therefore measures surplus, as baseball does. The price of a win comes from free-agent contracts (about $10M per win in 2026); the value produced is WAR × that price; the surplus, that value minus the contract's annual average. It is turned into a standard score within the role, then 0 to 100. Most recent season only.

Data: MLB (statsapi) and Baseball Savant; salaries updated daily.