Analysis
New York City FC
Matt Freese stands tall for New York City FC with four-save performance
In the MLS games played on Thursday, October 15, goalkeepers ruled the PickALeague board, with Matt Freese at the top.
· PickALeague

Dayne
St. Clair
G · MIA · Very poor
2026№ 31 / 34
#97G
Inter Miami CF
| Year | Team |
|---|
2026 season: 2,873 MIN, 74 SV, 125 SHOTS, 48 GA, -6.13 G+. WAR -0.2 (31st of 34) · PAL 7, very poor.
In 2026, Dayne St. Clair, 29, posts a PAL Rating of 7 out of 100 (very poor), and his WAR of -0.2 ranks 31st among 34 regulars, in the bottom quarter.
His strengths: distribution (93, among the best in the league). On the other hand, sweeping (1, among the weakest in the league) and shot stopping (10, among the weakest in the league) hold him back.
Breaking down his WAR (goals added), his biggest contribution: passing (+0.1); his biggest cost: shot-stopping (-1.1).
A marked decline: his PAL was 99 in 2025, against 7 now; his WAR went from 2.3 to -0.2.
Contract-wise, his Value score of 9 (very poor return) weighs his output against what he costs: 50 is what that salary should buy.
Growing up in the Toronto suburbs, Dayne St. Clair moved from outfield to the goal net in his teens, influenced by weekend matches where his father played as a goalkeeper and by time spent at local clubs including Vaughan Azzurri. He featured in Vaughan’s 2014 League1 Ontario Cup campaign before carving a path through summer PDL teams.
St. Clair joined the Maryland Terrapins programme after high school, spending a redshirt year in 2015 before becoming the regular starter by 2017. His final collegiate season was decisive: Maryland won the 2018 NCAA tournament, and he kept five straight clean sheets in the knockout rounds, earning the tournament’s defensive Most Outstanding Player award and finishing his Terrapins tenure with over forty appearances.
Professionally, St. Clair signed a Generation Adidas deal in January 2019 and was selected seventh overall in the MLS SuperDraft by Minnesota United. Early loan spells at Forward Madison and San Antonio preceded his MLS breakthrough when roster moves in 2020 allowed him to play the final stretch of the season and three playoff matches, recording eight clean sheets while conceding fifteen goals. He fought for consistency thereafter—losing the starting job in 2021, extending his contract through 2024, then reclaiming the number-one role in 2022 after another goalkeeper’s injury. That resurgence led to All-Star selections and end-of-season honours in subsequent years, and after parting ways with Minnesota at the end of 2025 he signed with Inter Miami in January 2026.
On the international front, St. Clair moved from a U23 provisional list in 2020 to the senior camp in early 2021 and made his Canada debut on 5 June 2021, a 7–0 World Cup qualifying win over Aruba in which he kept a clean sheet. He was included in squads for CONCACAF tournaments, travelled to the 2022 FIFA World Cup as a backup, and featured in the 2024 Copa América third-place match. Under coach Jesse Marsch he took on an increased starting role from mid-2024 through 2026, collecting seven clean sheets in that span and contributing to notable victories against Mexico and Wales before being named to Canada’s 2026 World Cup squad.
St. Clair’s game blends athletic shot-stopping with attention to positioning and angles, traits that have helped him turn temporary chances into sustained runs as a starter at both club and international levels.






Facts drawn from Wikipédia, told in our own words.
Guaranteed compensation: base salary plus signing bonuses and other guaranteed money, annualized; performance bonuses are not included. Contract length is not made public.
2026 season. The percentile ranks the player among regular goalkeepers (1,000+ minutes over a full season): 90th means better than 90% of them.
Saves
74
34th percentile
Shots on target faced
125
Save percentage
59.2 %
19th percentile
Goals conceded
48
Goals allowed − xG faced
+5.9
7th percentile
g+ per 90
−0.19
10th percentile
Pass completion
85.2 %
90th percentile
Minutes
2,873
Regular season. Goals allowed − xG faced: below zero, he allowed fewer goals than the quality of the shots on target predicted (lower is better). g+: goals added, above the position average. Data: American Soccer Analysis.
Projected WAR
0.9
80% of cases: -0.7 to 1.8
Confidence: medium · a goalkeeper's output swings a lot from season to season
Projected minutes
2,923
WAR 2026
-0.2
Minutes played
2,873
The pace of the last three seasons (WAR per minute, 60/25/15), pulled toward the group average as if 1,000 more minutes, over the minutes expected from the last two seasons, adjusted for age. Method chosen by backtest (2023 to 2026): mean error of 0.24 wins.
Trend
↓ Declining (-41)
The trend compares this season's WAR per 3,000 minutes with last season's (at least 500 minutes each), weighted by playing time. For goalkeepers, goals added swing a lot from season to season: read a strong trend with caution.
Outlook, age included
-41 · 29 y.o. · prime years
It is only a projection. It knows nothing about injuries, transfers or role changes.
Ratings from 0 to 100 drawn from data, never by hand: 75 = established regular, 95+ = elite. EX counts only his MLS seasons since 2021.
OV · Overall
72
Established starter
WAR: the goals added (g+) of each of his actions, above replacement level (the per-minute output of his group's fringe players), converted to standings points (0.64 points per goal), then to wins (3 points = one win). PAL Rating scores performance from 0 to 100 against regulars in the same group (50 = median).
WAR
-0.2
#31 of 34 regular goalkeepers
−0.9 goals above replacement
PAL Rating
7 / 100
#32 of 34 regular goalkeepers
Value Rating · 2026
Sporting contract value
9 / 100
The surplus: his 2026 WAR (-0.2) × the price of a win ($2.5M), minus his 2026 guaranteed compensation, against other goalkeepers. Commercial value (tickets, sponsors, media rights) is not counted.Salary$809KSurplus−$1.3MWAR paid0.33PAL: dimensions
Where WAR comes from (in wins)
Kicking and throwing: how his distribution changes his team's chances.
Catching or punching crosses rather than leaving them in the box.
Collecting loose balls and low crosses (counted with handling in his ratings).
Holding the shot or parrying it without giving up a rebound.
Coming off his line to cut out a ball in behind.
Goals prevented given the quality of the shots on target he faced.
The parts above are measured against the position average. This adjustment moves the baseline to a fringe player in his group, prorated by minutes: positive when fringe players do worse than average, negative when they do better.
Shot stopping drives almost all of a goalkeeper's WAR, and it swings a lot from season to season: one season says less than it does for an outfield player.
| Season | Team | Min | WAR | PAL | OV | Saves | Sv% | G − xG | g+/90 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | MIA | 2,873 | -0.2 | 7 | 72 | 74 | 59.2 | +5.9 | −0.19 |
| 2025 | MIN | 2,997 | 2.3 | 99 | 91 | 112 | 77.2 | −9.9 | +0.34 |
| 2024 | MIN | 2,653 | 1.3 | 75 | 80 | 69 | 69.7 | −1.8 | +0.10 |
| 2023 | MIN | 2,956 | 0.4 | 22 | 72 | 91 | 67.4 | +5.4 | −0.12 |
| 2022 | MIN | 3,094 | 2.4 | 85 | 80 | 109 | 70.3 | −2.4 | +0.12 |
Analysis
New York City FC
In the MLS games played on Thursday, October 15, goalkeepers ruled the PickALeague board, with Matt Freese at the top.
· PickALeague
Dayne St. Clair has 74 saves and has conceded 48 goals in 2,873 minutes in 2026.
Dayne St. Clair is 29 years old: he was born on May 9, 1997.
Dayne St. Clair is 6'3" (191 cm) and weighs 190 lb (86 kg).
Dayne St. Clair plays for the Inter Miami CF in the MLS, at G, wearing number 97.
Dayne St. Clair produced -0.2 wins above replacement (WAR) in 2026, 32nd of 34 players at his position in the MLS. His PAL rating is 7 out of 100: very poor for his position.
Dayne St. Clair earns $809K for the 2026 season. His Value Rating (on-field contract efficiency) is 9 out of 100 (very poor return): it measures the on-field return for that salary, compared with players at his position; the player's commercial value is not part of it.
Yes, his output falls short of what his salary should buy. His Value rating is 9 out of 100 (very poor return), where 50 is the output expected for his salary, compared with players at his position.
No: by WAR, he ranks 32nd of 34 players at his position in the MLS in 2026. Our comparison tool puts him side by side with any other player.
No, he is slipping: his PAL rating went from 99 in 2025 to 7 in 2026 (out of 100, 50 = average player at his position).
Kristijan Kahlina: he is the player at his position whose PAL profile (the 0-to-100 dimensions) is closest to his in 2026.
Kristijan Kahlina's page →Dayne St. Clair is Canadian. Internationally: Canada — selected and appeared for the senior team (debut June 5, 2021). Member of squads for the 2021 Gold Cup, 2022 FIFA World Cup, 2023 CONCACAF Nations League Finals, 2023 Gold Cup, 2024 Copa América (started third-place match), 2025 Gold Cup, and named to the 2026 FIFA World Cup squad.
NCAA Tournament Defensive MVP: 2018 ; MLS All-Star: 2022 ; MLS All-Star: 2025 ; MLS All-Star Game MVP: 2022 ; MLS Best XI: 2025 ; MLS Goalkeeper of the Year: 2025.
3: Vaughan Azzurri — League1 Ontario Cup: 2014; Maryland Terrapins — NCAA Division I men's soccer tournament (national championship): 2018; Inter Miami — Campeones Cup: 2026.
Youth and PDL: Epiphany Church Soccer League (from age 3), North Scarborough SC, Pickering SC, Ajax SC, Vaughan Azzurri (2014–2015, won 2014 League1 Ontario Cup), K–W United FC (PDL 2016–2017, 13 appearances), New York Red Bulls U23 (PDL 2018, 3 appearances). College: Maryland Terrapins (redshirt 2015, backup 2016, starter 2017–2018, 43 appearances)..
Our projection has him at 0.9 WAR in 2027, based on his weighted recent seasons and age.