PickALeague.com
70Rookie · RCPayton Tolle headshot

Payton

Tolle

P · BOS · Elite

PAL
94
WAR
4.1
Value
95
ERA
3.03

2026№ 15 / 166

Payton Tolle

#70PBoston Red Sox logoBoston Red Sox

Biography

Height
6' 6"
Weight
113 kg
Bats
L
Throws
L
MLB debut
August 29, 2025
Born
November 1, 2002 (24)
Birthplace
Stillwater, OK, USA
Draft
2024

MLB record

YearTeamPJVDMPMMJRBWHIP
2026Boston Red Sox26963.03148.21711.10
2025Boston Red Sox7016.0616.1191.59
Career totals33973.33165.01901.15

Payton Tolle: our analysis

2026 season: 26 G, 148.7 IP, 9 W, 6 L, 171 SO, 1.10 WHIP. WAR 4.1 (15th of 166) · PAL 94, elite.

Payton Tolle is in his first season in the league. In 2026, He posts a PAL Rating of 94 out of 100 (elite), and his WAR of 4.1 ranks 15th among 166 regulars, in the top quarter.

His strengths: contact allowed (95, among the best in the league), run prevention (92, among the best in the league) and stuff (91, among the best in the league).

Contract-wise, his Value score of 95 (exceptional value) weighs his output against what he costs: 50 is what that salary should buy.

Payton Tolle's story

Growing up in Bethany, Oklahoma, Payton Tolle developed as a two-way player before concentrating on pitching at the collegiate level. His early years at Bethany High School led to Wichita State, where he split duties as a hitter and a pitcher and learned both sides of the game in live competition.

Tolle’s sophomore season at Wichita State in 2023 was a breakout: he hit .320 while posting a 9–2 record on the mound and was a finalist for the John Olerud Award. He transferred to TCU for 2024 and earned Big 12 Pitcher of the Year honours after going 7–4 with a 3.21 ERA and 125 strikeouts in 81 1/3 innings, a season that raised his draft profile considerably.

Selected by the Boston Red Sox in the second round of the 2024 MLB draft, Tolle signed for $2 million and began his professional career in 2025. He started with the Greenville Drive, moved up to the Portland Sea Dogs in June and reached Triple-A Worcester in early August. Across those three levels he posted a 3.04 ERA, a 0.99 WHIP and 133 strikeouts over 91 2/3 innings, numbers that prompted his call to the majors.

Boston promoted Tolle on August 29, 2025; in his big-league debut against Pittsburgh he worked 5 2/3 innings, allowed two earned runs and struck out eight. A pair of tougher starts led to a move to the bullpen for the rest of that season, but he was added to Boston’s roster for the AL Wild Card Series against New York.

The 2026 campaign featured more movement between Worcester and Boston. Optioned to Triple-A to begin the year, he was recalled April 23 and notched his first major-league win on May 4 with seven innings against Detroit. On August 7 he struck out 14 in six innings, the most strikeouts by a Red Sox starter at that age since Roger Clemens, and on September 13 he recorded an immaculate inning—the first by a Red Sox pitcher since Chris Sale’s in 2021. Those milestones underline his strikeout ability and capacity to deliver dominant innings.

Facts drawn from Wikipédia, told in our own words.

Type
Pre-Arbitration
Length
1 yr · 2027–2027
Total value
0.0 M$
AAV
—

Advanced stats, 2026 Starting pitcher

MLB stats →

ERA

3.03

FIP

3.04

xFIP

3.55

ERA-

71

WHIP

1.10

K%

28.4 %

BB%

6.6 %

Strikeouts

171

Innings

148.7

Wins

9

Stats: MLB (statsapi) and Baseball Savant.

2027 projection

MLB trends →

Projected WAR

2.4

80% of cases: 1.0 to 4.2

Strikeouts

100

2026 WAR

4.1

This season's pace, over the average of the last two workloads, adjusted for next year's age.

Trend

→ Stable (0)

  • 2025-0.2 WAR
  • 20264.1 WAR · 5.0 per full season

Outlook, age included

+25 · 23 y.o. · usually still improving

It is only a projection. It knows nothing about injuries, trades or role changes.

Player ratings, 2026

All ratings →

Ratings from 0 to 100 drawn from Statcast, never by hand: 75 = established regular, 95+ = elite.

OV · Overall

87

High-end

VEL
Velocity
83
STF
Stuff
86
CTL
Control
80
CNT
Contact allowed
90
STA
Stamina
72
DUR
Durability
70
EX
Experience
37
Why these ratings?
  • VEL — Velocity : Fastball velocity
  • STF — Stuff : Strikeouts, K − BB
  • CTL — Control : Walks avoided
  • CNT — Contact allowed : xwOBA, barrels and hard-hit balls allowed
  • STA — Stamina : Innings per start and innings pitched
  • DUR — Durability : Games played over several seasons
  • EX — Experience : Seasons in the majors

WAR and PAL Rating, 2026

How we rate →

WAR is fWAR (FanGraphs' version, distributed through MLB's API): wins added above a replacement player. PAL Rating scores performance from 0 to 100 against regulars in the same role (50 = median).

PAL: dimensions

Run prevention92
Stuff91
Command77
Contact allowed95
Velocity79
Workload65

A pitcher's WAR

Computed by MLB from FIP (strikeouts, walks, home runs). FIP: 3.04 · RA9-WAR: 4.4

MLB's tracking of every ball, 2026 season. The percentile ranks the player among regulars in the role: 90th means better than 90% of them.

Fastball

96.1 mi/h

78th percentile

K%

28.4 %

91th percentile

BB%

6.6 %

78th percentile

xERA

2.70

98th percentile

xwOBA allowed

.255

98th percentile

Barrels allowed

6.0 %

85th percentile

Season by season
SeasonTeamWARPALOVFastballK%BB%xERAxwOBA allowed
2026BOS4.1948796.128.46.62.70.255
2025BOS-0.2397696.725.710.84.67.333

Game log, 2026

DateOpponentIPHERBBSOERA
Sep 22vs CLE5.282253.03
Sep 13vs KC6.040173.02
Sep 6@ BAL6.0410123.15
Aug 31vs SEA5.264263.23
Aug 25@ MIA5.142273.09
Aug 19vs AZ5.063263.08
Aug 13@ TOR8.020242.97
Aug 7vs ATH6.0210143.20
Aug 1@ LAD6.092273.30
Jul 27@ ATH5.152173.32

Payton Tolle: frequently asked questions

What is Payton Tolle's record in 2026?

Payton Tolle is 9-6 in 2026, with a 3.03 ERA and 171 strikeouts in 148.7 innings.

How old is Payton Tolle?

Payton Tolle is 24 years old: he was born on November 1, 2002.

How tall is Payton Tolle, and how much does he weigh?

Payton Tolle is 6'6" (198 cm) and weighs 249 lb (113 kg).

Where is Payton Tolle from?

United States: Payton Tolle was born in Stillwater, OK, United States.

What team does Payton Tolle play for?

Payton Tolle plays for the Boston Red Sox in the MLB, at P, wearing number 70.

How good is Payton Tolle?

Payton Tolle produced 4.1 wins above replacement (WAR) in 2026, 16th of 166 players at his position in the MLB. His PAL rating is 94 out of 100: elite for his position.

How much does Payton Tolle make?

Payton Tolle earns $782K for the 2026 season. His Value Rating is 95 out of 100 (exceptional value): it measures the on-field return for that salary, compared with players at his position.

Is Payton Tolle overpaid?

No, he gives more than he costs. His Value rating is 95 out of 100 (exceptional value), where 50 is the output expected for his salary, compared with players at his position.

Is Payton Tolle a top-10 player at his position?

No: by WAR, he ranks 16th of 166 players at his position in the MLB in 2026. Our comparison tool puts him side by side with any other player.

Where was Payton Tolle drafted?

Payton Tolle: 2024.

Which player is most similar to Payton Tolle?

Zack Wheeler: he is the player at his position whose PAL profile (the 0-to-100 dimensions) is closest to his in 2026.

Zack Wheeler's page →

Is Payton Tolle married?

Yes, married to Devin Melton in 2026.

What is Payton Tolle's nationality?

Payton Tolle is American.

What awards has Payton Tolle won?

Finalist for the John Olerud Award (2023) ; Big 12 Pitcher of the Year (2024).

Where did Payton Tolle play before turning pro?

Bethany High School (Bethany, Oklahoma); Wichita State University — Shockers (sophomore season in 2023); transferred to Texas Christian University — Horned Frogs (2024).

What is Payton Tolle's projection for 2027?

Our projection has him at 2.4 WAR in 2027, based on his weighted recent seasons and age.

See also: his Boston Red Sox teammates

Full roster →