Joining Toronto FC’s academy at 12 set the course of Petrasso’s career, and he moved up to the Senior Academy in League1 Ontario in 2016. He marked his senior debut on June 4 with an 86th-minute winner against ProStars FC and, the following year on September 23, turned in a four-goal performance versus North Mississauga SC.
He signed his first professional contract on March 15, 2018 with Toronto FC II and made his pro debut on April 26 against the Richmond Kickers. His first professional goal came on April 6, 2019 against Orlando City B — a milestone that doubled as the club’s inaugural USL League One goal after the team moved to the third tier. He remained with the reserve side and re-signed for the 2021 season.
Toronto FC promoted him to the senior roster as a Homegrown Player on January 11, 2022, under a contract through 2023. Petrasso made his MLS debut on March 5, starting against the New York Red Bulls and supplying an assist on Jesús Jiménez’s goal in a 4–1 loss. Orlando City acquired him in a trade on November 9, 2022 for General Allocation Money; that contract was allowed to expire on December 5, 2024.
On January 12, 2024 he moved to Italy on loan to Serie C side Triestina with an option to buy, starting his debut on January 20 in a 2–1 win over Pro Vercelli. He made 14 appearances during the loan spell, but Triestina did not exercise the purchase option. CF Montréal invited him to training camp on January 13, 2025 and signed him on February 7 to a one-year deal with club options; he started the season opener on February 22, scored his first goal for the club and his first MLS goal on May 14 in a 1–1 draw with Columbus Crew, and added an equalizer on August 16 against D.C. United, earning a spot on the Team of the Matchday bench for the first time before Montréal extended his contract at season’s end.
Internationally, Petrasso featured for Canada at the 2017 CONCACAF U-17 Championship, appeared on preliminary rosters for senior competitions in 2023 and 2024, and received his first senior call-up on October 3, 2026 ahead of the Peru match. Born in Canada with Italian heritage and holding dual citizenship, he is the younger brother of Michael Petrasso and won the Canadian Championship with Toronto FC in 2020.