PickALeague.com
22BaseKevin O'Toole headshot

Kevin

O'Toole

D · NYC · Very poor

PAL
2
WAR
-0.3
Value
11
G+A
1

2026№ 86 / 90

Kevin O'Toole

#22DNew York City FC logoNew York City FC

Biography

Team
New York City FC
Position
Defender
Height
5' 10"
Weight
150 lbs
Born
December 14, 1998 (27)
Status
Active

MLS record

YearTeam

Kevin O'Toole: our analysis

2026 season: 1,972 MIN, 0 G, 1 A, 0.9 xG, 0.9 xA, 7 SHOTS. WAR -0.3 (86th of 90) · PAL 2, very poor.

In 2026, Kevin O'Toole, 27, posts a PAL Rating of 2 out of 100 (very poor), and his WAR of -0.3 ranks 86th among 90 regulars, in the bottom quarter.

On the other hand, discipline (9, among the weakest in the league) and passing (13, among the weakest in the league) hold him back.

Breaking down his WAR (goals added), no component is positive; the costliest: passing (-0.2).

A marked decline: his PAL was 22 in 2025, against 2 now; his WAR went from -0.1 to -0.3.

Contract-wise, his Value score of 11 (very poor return) weighs his output against what he costs: 50 is what that salary should buy.

Kevin O'Toole's story

Born 14 December 1998 in the United States, Kevin O'Toole came through the New York Red Bulls academy and first appeared in competitive action with their under-17/18 side during the 2015/16 season, playing in two matches before stepping up to senior reserve football.

In 2016 he featured for New York Red Bulls II on an amateur contract, making his debut at 17. He opened his professional goal account on 23 July in a 3–2 loss to Charleston Battery and was a starter in the USL Cup Final on 23 October 2016, when Red Bulls II beat Swope Park Rangers 5–1.

O'Toole's path led him to New York City FC when the club selected him 34th overall in the 2022 MLS SuperDraft. He signed officially with NYCFC on 7 March 2022 and has since been part of their squad in Major League Soccer, adding top-flight experience to the foundation built in the Red Bulls system.

Internationally he qualifies for the Republic of Ireland through a grandfather born in Dublin and received his first Ireland call-up on 6 November 2025 from head coach Heimir Hallgrímsson for 2026 World Cup qualifying matches against Portugal and Hungary.

A left-back by trade, O'Toole's career highlights include team silverware at both levels: the USL Cup with New York Red Bulls II in 2016 and the Campeones Cup with New York City FC in 2022. The family connection to the game extends to his sister Jillian, who has played in the LOI Women's Premier Division for Treaty United.

Kevin O'Toole in action for New York City FC on April 22, 2026
Kevin O'Toole during New York City FC vs FC Cincinnati on April 22, 2026.Photo: Bryan Berlin · CC BY-SA 4.0
Kevin O'Toole with Ender Echenique during NYCFC vs Cincinnati on April 22, 2026
Ender Echenique and Kevin O'Toole during New York City FC vs FC Cincinnati on April 22, 2026.Photo: Bryan Berlin · CC BY-SA 4.0
Kevin O'Toole with Paxten Aaronson during NYCFC vs Colorado on March 14, 2026
Kevin O'Toole and Paxten Aaronson during New York City FC vs Colorado Rapids on March 14, 2026.Photo: Bryan Berlin · CC BY-SA 4.0
Kevin O'Toole playing for New York City FC on March 14, 2026
Kevin O'Toole during New York City FC vs Colorado Rapids on March 14, 2026.Photo: Bryan Berlin · CC BY-SA 4.0
Kevin O'Toole during Philadelphia Union vs New York City FC on November 23, 2025
Kevin O'Toole during Philadelphia Union vs New York City FC on November 23, 2025.Photo: Bryan Berlin · CC BY-SA 4.0

Facts drawn from Wikipédia, told in our own words.

2026 guaranteed comp.
323 k$
Base salary
300 k$
Rank on the club
#16 of 32

Guaranteed compensation: base salary plus signing bonuses and other guaranteed money, annualized; performance bonuses are not included. Contract length is not made public.

Advanced stats, 2026 Fullbacks

MLS stats →

2026 season. The percentile ranks the player among regular fullbacks (1,000+ minutes over a full season): 90th means better than 90% of them.

Goals

0

19th percentile

Assists

1

42th percentile

Expected goals (xG)

0.9

44th percentile

Expected assists (xA)

0.9

17th percentile

Goals − xG

−0.9

16th percentile

Key passes

11

29th percentile

Pass completion

85.4 %

81th percentile

Passes over expected

+1.0 /100

48th percentile

g+ per 90

−0.11

2th percentile

Minutes

1,972

Regular season. xG: expected goals from chance quality; xA: expected assists. Passes over expected: completed passes above expectation, per 100 passes, given their difficulty. g+: goals added, above the position average. Data: American Soccer Analysis.

2027 projection

MLS trends →

Projected WAR

-0.1

80% of cases: -0.3 to 0.1

Confidence: high · based on the backtest and minutes played

Projected minutes

2,024

WAR 2026

-0.3

Minutes played

1,972

The pace of the last three seasons (WAR per minute, 60/25/15), pulled toward the group average as if 1,000 more minutes, over the minutes expected from the last two seasons, adjusted for age. Method chosen by backtest (2023 to 2026): mean error of 0.24 wins.

Trend

→ Stable (-5)

  • 2023-0.1 WAR · -0.22 per 3,000 min
  • 20240.0 WAR · 0.00 per 3,000 min
  • 2025-0.1 WAR · -0.14 per 3,000 min
  • 2026-0.3 WAR · -0.46 per 3,000 min

The trend compares this season's WAR per 3,000 minutes with last season's (at least 500 minutes each), weighted by playing time.

Outlook, age included

-5 · 27 y.o. · prime years

It is only a projection. It knows nothing about injuries, transfers or role changes.

Player ratings, 2026

All ratings →

Ratings from 0 to 100 drawn from data, never by hand: 75 = established regular, 95+ = elite. EX counts only his MLS seasons since 2021.

OV · Overall

57

Backup or prospect

DEF
Defending
63
PAS
Passing
68
VIS
Vision
67
DRI
Dribbling
61
DIS
Discipline
75
DUR
Durability
78
EX
Experience
70
Why these ratings?
  • DEF — Defending : Goals added by interrupting (tackles, interceptions, clearances)
  • PAS — Passing : Goals added by passing, passes completed over expected
  • VIS — Vision : Expected assists and key passes per 90
  • DRI — Dribbling : Goals added by carrying the ball
  • DIS — Discipline : Goals added by fouls drawn and avoided
  • DUR — Durability : Share of his club's minutes played, over several seasons
  • EX — Experience : MLS seasons since 2021 (our data)

WAR and PAL Rating, 2026

How we rate →

WAR: the goals added (g+) of each of his actions, above replacement level (the per-minute output of his group's fringe players), converted to standings points (0.64 points per goal), then to wins (3 points = one win). PAL Rating scores performance from 0 to 100 against regulars in the same group (50 = median).

PAL: dimensions

Defending16
Passing13
Chance creation18
Dribbling25
Discipline9
Receiving46

Where WAR comes from (in wins)

Receiving−0.01

Getting open and receiving the ball in dangerous areas.

Shooting−0.03

The value of his shots: the quality of the chance and what he makes of it.

Dribbling−0.04

Carrying the ball and beating defenders, minus the balls lost.

Fouling−0.05

Fouls drawn (free kicks, penalties won) minus fouls committed.

Interrupting−0.12

Breaking up the opponent's play: tackles, interceptions, clearances, blocked shots.

Passing−0.24

How his passes change his team's chances of scoring and conceding.

Replacement adjustment+0.17

The parts above are measured against the position average. This adjustment moves the baseline to a fringe player in his group, prorated by minutes: positive when fringe players do worse than average, negative when they do better.

Season by season
SeasonTeamMinWARPALOVGAxGxAg+/90
2026NYC1,972-0.3257010.90.9−0.11
2025NYC2,101-0.12265110.61.5−0.03
2024NYC2,7140.04169121.22.6−0.02
2023NYC1,366-0.11450000.30.8−0.06
2022NYC302-0.1551000.10.0−0.16

Kevin O'Toole: frequently asked questions

How many goals does Kevin O'Toole have in 2026?

Kevin O'Toole has 0 goals and 1 assist in 1,972 minutes in 2026 (expected goals: 0.9).

How old is Kevin O'Toole?

Kevin O'Toole is 27 years old: he was born on December 14, 1998.

How tall is Kevin O'Toole, and how much does he weigh?

Kevin O'Toole is 5'10" (178 cm) and weighs 150 lb (68 kg).

What team does Kevin O'Toole play for?

Kevin O'Toole plays for the New York City FC in the MLS, at D, wearing number 22.

How good is Kevin O'Toole?

Kevin O'Toole produced -0.3 wins above replacement (WAR) in 2026, 89th of 90 players at his position in the MLS. His PAL rating is 2 out of 100: very poor for his position.

How much does Kevin O'Toole make?

Kevin O'Toole earns $323K for the 2026 season. His Value Rating (on-field contract efficiency) is 11 out of 100 (very poor return): it measures the on-field return for that salary, compared with players at his position; the player's commercial value is not part of it.

Is Kevin O'Toole overpaid?

Yes, his output falls short of what his salary should buy. His Value rating is 11 out of 100 (very poor return), where 50 is the output expected for his salary, compared with players at his position.

Is Kevin O'Toole a top-10 player at his position?

No: by WAR, he ranks 89th of 90 players at his position in the MLS in 2026. Our comparison tool puts him side by side with any other player.

Is Kevin O'Toole getting better?

No, he is slipping: his PAL rating went from 22 in 2025 to 2 in 2026 (out of 100, 50 = average player at his position).

Which player is most similar to Kevin O'Toole?

Daniel Lovitz: he is the player at his position whose PAL profile (the 0-to-100 dimensions) is closest to his in 2026.

Daniel Lovitz's page →

Does Kevin O'Toole have siblings?

Yes: his sister Jillian (played for Treaty United in the LOI Women's Premier Division).

What is Kevin O'Toole's nationality?

Kevin O'Toole is Irish. Internationally: Republic of Ireland — first call-up on 6 November 2025 for 2026 FIFA World Cup qualification fixtures (against Portugal and Hungary).

How many championships has Kevin O'Toole won?

2: Campeones Cup 2022 with New York City FC; USL Cup 2016 with New York Red Bulls II.

Where did Kevin O'Toole play before turning pro?

New York Red Bulls Academy — appeared 2015/16 for the U‑17/18 team; signed an amateur contract with New York Red Bulls II in 2016.

What is Kevin O'Toole's projection for 2027?

Our projection has him at -0.1 WAR in 2027, based on his weighted recent seasons and age.

See also: his New York City FC teammates

Full roster →