PickALeague.com
77BaseJohn McCarthy headshot

John

McCarthy

G · RBNY · Very poor

PAL
1
WAR
-1.1
SAVES
35

2025№ 32 / 35

John McCarthy

#77GNew York Red Bulls logoNew York Red Bulls

Biography

Team
New York Red Bulls
Position
Goalkeeper
Height
6' 1"
Weight
183 lbs
Born
July 4, 1992 (34)
Status
Active

MLS record

YearTeam

John McCarthy: our analysis

2025 season: 1,212 MIN, 35 SV, 64 SHOTS, 27 GA, -4.74 G+. WAR -1.1 (32nd of 35) · PAL 1, very poor.

In 2025, John McCarthy, 34, posts a PAL Rating of 1 out of 100 (very poor), and his WAR of -1.1 ranks 32nd among 35 regulars, in the bottom quarter.

His strengths: handling (96, among the best in the league) and claiming (84, well above average). On the other hand, distribution (1, among the weakest in the league) and shot stopping (1, among the weakest in the league) hold him back.

Breaking down his WAR (goals added), no component is positive; the costliest: shot-stopping (-0.9).

A marked decline: his PAL was 81 in 2024, against 1 now; his WAR went from 1.7 to -1.1.

John McCarthy's story

As a high school goalkeeper for the Northeast Catholic Falcons, John McCarthy helped his team claim both the Catholic League and City Championships in 2008; that early success was later honoured with induction into the North Catholic Soccer Hall of Fame in 2026. Those formative years set the tone for a career focused squarely on goalkeeping.

He spent 2010–2013 at La Salle University, where he established several career records, including appearances, saves and clean sheets. During his college summers he gained additional match experience with Ocean City Nor'easters (2011–2012) and Reading United in 2013. Conference recognition came as well, with Atlantic 10 All‑Conference honours across his junior and senior years.

McCarthy turned professional when he signed with the Rochester Rhinos on 27 February 2014. He made an immediate impression, leading the league with a 0.72 goals‑against average and earning both USL Pro Rookie of the Year and Goalkeeper of the Year distinctions. That breakout season led to a move back home, joining Philadelphia Union in 2015. Thrust into a starting role by circumstances, he made his MLS debut on 11 April 2015 against New York City FC and featured in the Union’s run to the U.S. Open Cup final; he also spent time on loan with Bethlehem Steel FC in 2016, where he recorded multiple shutouts.

McCarthy continued his career with the Tampa Bay Rowdies after signing on 31 January 2019, then moved to Inter Miami in December 2019 and debuted for them on 7 October 2020 against New York Red Bulls. Los Angeles FC signed him on 21 January 2022, and he played a decisive role in the MLS Cup 2022 final when he was brought on late, saved kicks in the shootout and was named the match MVP as LAFC captured the club’s first title. A transfer to LA Galaxy followed on 5 January 2024, yielding another MLS Cup in 2024, before New York Red Bulls acquired him in a trade on 22 August 2025.

McCarthy’s game is defined by steadiness and big‑moment composure: he relies on positioning, shot‑stopping instincts and a proven ability to influence outcomes in penalty shootouts and knockout matches.

John McCarthy in action for New York Red Bulls, October 2026
John McCarthy during New York Red Bulls vs San Diego FC, 10 October 2026.Photo: Bryan Berlin · CC BY-SA 4.0
John McCarthy for New York Red Bulls vs New England Revolution, February 2026
John McCarthy during New York Red Bulls vs New England Revolution at Sports Illustrated Stadium, 28 February 2026.Photo: Bryan Berlin · CC BY-SA 4.0
John McCarthy in USL match with Bethlehem Steel FC at Nippert Stadium, 2018
Taken during FC Cincinnati vs Bethlehem Steel FC at Nippert Stadium, 13 June 2018.Photo: Hayden Schiff from Cincinnati, USA · CC BY 2.0
John McCarthy with Bethlehem Steel FC on the road in Cincinnati, June 2018
Image from the match FC Cincinnati vs Bethlehem Steel FC at Nippert Stadium, 13 June 2018.Photo: Hayden Schiff from Cincinnati, USA · CC BY 2.0
John McCarthy in action for Philadelphia Union at Avaya Stadium, August 2017
John McCarthy playing for Philadelphia Union at Avaya Stadium on 19 August 2017.Photo: Noah Salzman · CC BY-SA 4.0

Facts drawn from Wikipédia, told in our own words.

2026 guaranteed comp.
589 k$
Base salary
525 k$
Rank on the club
#6 of 24

Guaranteed compensation: base salary plus signing bonuses and other guaranteed money, annualized; performance bonuses are not included. Contract length is not made public.

Advanced stats, 2025 Goalkeepers

MLS stats →

2025 season. The percentile ranks the player among regular goalkeepers (1,000+ minutes over a full season): 90th means better than 90% of them.

Saves

35

7th percentile

Shots on target faced

64

Save percentage

54.7 %

4th percentile

Goals conceded

27

Goals allowed − xG faced

+4.6

10th percentile

g+ per 90

−0.35

1th percentile

Pass completion

61.8 %

7th percentile

Minutes

1,212

Regular season. Goals allowed − xG faced: below zero, he allowed fewer goals than the quality of the shots on target predicted (lower is better). g+: goals added, above the position average. Data: American Soccer Analysis.

2026 projection

MLS trends →

Projected WAR

0.0

80% of cases: -0.7 to 1.0

Confidence: medium · a goalkeeper's output swings a lot from season to season

Projected minutes

2,034

WAR 2025

-1.1

Minutes played

1,212

The pace of the last three seasons (WAR per minute, 60/25/15), pulled toward the group average as if 1,000 more minutes, over the minutes expected from the last two seasons, adjusted for age. Method chosen by backtest (2023 to 2026): mean error of 0.24 wins.

Trend

↓ Declining (-46)

  • 20230.7 WAR · 0.83 per 3,000 min
  • 20241.7 WAR · 1.56 per 3,000 min
  • 2025-1.1 WAR · -2.72 per 3,000 min

The trend compares this season's WAR per 3,000 minutes with last season's (at least 500 minutes each), weighted by playing time. For goalkeepers, goals added swing a lot from season to season: read a strong trend with caution.

Outlook, age included

-61 · 32 y.o. · the age when performance usually declines

It is only a projection. It knows nothing about injuries, transfers or role changes.

Player ratings, 2025

All ratings →

Ratings from 0 to 100 drawn from data, never by hand: 75 = established regular, 95+ = elite. EX counts only his MLS seasons since 2021.

OV · Overall

63

Depth player

SAV
Shot stopping
65
DST
Distribution
46
CLM
Claiming
80
SWP
Sweeping
74
DUR
Durability
68
EX
Experience
70
Why these ratings?
  • SAV — Shot stopping : Goals allowed against post-shot expected goals, shot-stopping g+
  • DST — Distribution : Goals added by distribution
  • CLM — Claiming : Goals added by claiming crosses
  • SWP — Sweeping : Goals added by sweeping
  • DUR — Durability : Share of his club's minutes played, over several seasons
  • EX — Experience : MLS seasons since 2021 (our data)

WAR and PAL Rating, 2025

How we rate →

WAR: the goals added (g+) of each of his actions, above replacement level (the per-minute output of his group's fringe players), converted to standings points (0.64 points per goal), then to wins (3 points = one win). PAL Rating scores performance from 0 to 100 against regulars in the same group (50 = median).

PAL: dimensions

Shot stopping1
Distribution1
Claiming84
Sweeping7
Handling96

Where WAR comes from (in wins)

Handling+0.04

Holding the shot or parrying it without giving up a rebound.

Fielding+0.03

Collecting loose balls and low crosses (counted with handling in his ratings).

Claiming+0.02

Catching or punching crosses rather than leaving them in the box.

Sweeping−0.07

Coming off his line to cut out a ball in behind.

Distribution−0.12

Kicking and throwing: how his distribution changes his team's chances.

Shot stopping−0.91

Goals prevented given the quality of the shots on target he faced.

Replacement adjustment−0.06

The parts above are measured against the position average. This adjustment moves the baseline to a fringe player in his group, prorated by minutes: positive when fringe players do worse than average, negative when they do better.

Shot stopping drives almost all of a goalkeeper's WAR, and it swings a lot from season to season: one season says less than it does for an outfield player.

Season by season
SeasonTeamMinWARPALOVSavesSv%G − xGg+/90
2025LA1,212-1.11633554.7+4.6−0.35
2024LA3,2681.7817812571.8−2.4+0.11
2023LAFC2,5180.725606767.7+1.6−0.05

John McCarthy: frequently asked questions

What is John McCarthy's record in 2025?

John McCarthy has 35 saves and has conceded 27 goals in 1,212 minutes in 2025.

How old is John McCarthy?

John McCarthy is 34 years old: he was born on July 4, 1992.

How tall is John McCarthy, and how much does he weigh?

John McCarthy is 6'1" (185 cm) and weighs 183 lb (83 kg).

What team does John McCarthy play for?

John McCarthy plays for the New York Red Bulls in the MLS, at G, wearing number 77.

How good is John McCarthy?

John McCarthy produced -1.1 wins above replacement (WAR) in 2025, 32nd of 35 players at his position in the MLS. His PAL rating is 1 out of 100: very poor for his position.

How much does John McCarthy make?

John McCarthy earns $475K for the 2025 season.

Is John McCarthy a top-10 player at his position?

No: by WAR, he ranks 32nd of 35 players at his position in the MLS in 2025. Our comparison tool puts him side by side with any other player.

Is John McCarthy getting better?

No, he is slipping: his PAL rating went from 81 in 2024 to 1 in 2025 (out of 100, 50 = average player at his position).

What is John McCarthy's nationality?

John McCarthy is American.

What awards has John McCarthy won?

United Soccer League Rookie of the Year: 2014 ; United Soccer League Goalkeeper of the Year: 2014 ; United Soccer League All‑League First Team: 2014 ; MLS Cup Most Valuable Player: 2022 ; CONCACAF Champions League Golden Glove: 2023 ; CONCACAF Champions League Best XI: 2023.

How many championships has John McCarthy won?

3: MLS Cup with Los Angeles FC: 2022; Supporters' Shield with Los Angeles FC: 2022; MLS Cup with LA Galaxy: 2024.

Where did John McCarthy play before turning pro?

High school: Northeast Catholic Falcons (goalkeeper); in 2008 helped lead them to a Catholic League and City Championship. College: La Salle University (2010–2013). USL PDL clubs: Ocean City Nor'easters (2011–2012), Reading United AC (2013)..

What is John McCarthy's projection for 2026?

Our projection has him at 0.0 WAR in 2026, based on his weighted recent seasons and age.

See also: his New York Red Bulls teammates

Full roster →