PickALeague.com
96RareShy Tuttle headshot

Shy

Tuttle

DT · WAS · Above average

PAL
65
WAR
0.0
Value
75
SACKS
2.0

2026

Shy Tuttle

#96DTWashington Commanders logoWashington Commanders

Biography

Team
Washington Commanders
Position
Defensive Tackle
Height
6' 3"
Weight
300 lbs
Born
October 20, 1995 (31)
Birthplace
Midway, NC
College
Tennessee
Experience
8th Season
Status
Active

Career history

  • Washington Commanders · 2026 (1 season)
  • 2025 Totals · 2025 (1 season)
  • Washington Commanders · 2025 (1 season)
  • Tennessee Titans · 2025 (1 season)
  • Carolina Panthers · 2023 – 2024 (2 seasons)
  • New Orleans Saints · 2019 – 2022 (4 seasons)

NFL record

YearTeamGPTOTSOLOASTSACKFFFRYDS
2026Washington Commanders9209112010
20252025 Totals1215780000
2025Washington Commanders24130000
2025Tennessee Titans1011650000
2024Carolina Panthers154622240120
2023Carolina Panthers174319240.5000
2022New Orleans Saints174926232000
2021New Orleans Saints174817310110
2020New Orleans Saints132817110000
2019New Orleans Saints16188102000

Shy Tuttle: our analysis

2026 season: 9 GP, 20 TKL, 2.0 SACKS, 4 TFL, 0 INT, 0 PD. WAR 0.0 · PAL 65, above average.

In 2026, Shy Tuttle, 31, posts a PAL Rating of 65 out of 100 (above average), with a WAR of 0.0.

His strengths: run defense (85, among the best in the league), tackling (80, well above average) and splash plays (62, above average). On the other hand, pass rush (26, below average) holds him back.

A clear step forward: his PAL went from 30 in 2025 to 65; his WAR, though, went from 0.0 to 0.0.

Contract-wise, his Value score of 75 (very good contract) weighs his output against what he costs: 50 is what that salary should buy.

Shy Tuttle's story

A four‑year starter at North Davidson High, Shy Tuttle finished his high school career with 315 tackles, 66 tackles for loss and 35 sacks, earning All‑Northwest North Carolina honours in each of his final three seasons and a spot in the 2015 Under Armour All‑American Game. Born and raised in Midway, North Carolina, he also competed in basketball and track and field before concentrating on football.

At Tennessee, Tuttle’s college tenure stretched across four seasons but was interrupted by serious injuries: a broken fibula and torn ankle ligament after six games as a freshman, and another season‑ending injury in his first career start as a sophomore. He returned to play in later years, contributing 27 tackles (2.5 for loss) as a junior and closing his senior year as a full‑time starter with 33 tackles, one sack, an interception and two blocked kicks.

Undrafted in 2019, Tuttle signed with the New Orleans Saints on April 27, 2019, and made his NFL debut in the season opener. Early highlights included a half‑sack on Deshaun Watson in that first game and an interception of Matt Ryan on Thanksgiving in Week 13 that drew national attention. He appeared in all 16 regular‑season games in 2019 and played in the Wild Card playoff; over the next three seasons he became a steady presence on the interior defensive line, appearing in every game in both 2021 and 2022 and posting 49 tackles and two sacks in 2022.

On March 15, 2023, Tuttle signed a three‑year, $19.5 million contract with the Carolina Panthers. He started all 17 games in 2023 and 15 games in 2024, registering tackles, several passes defended and a forced fumble in 2024. The Panthers released him on August 26, 2025; he signed with the Tennessee Titans on August 27, made 10 appearances with one start and 11 tackles, and was released on December 20.

Claimed off waivers by the Washington Commanders on December 22, 2025, Tuttle signed a one‑year extension with Washington on March 9, 2026, was released in final cuts on August 30 then re‑signed the next day. He is the nephew of former NFL receiver Perry Tuttle and is known for occupying interior gaps, clogging the running lanes and disrupting passing plays.

Shy Tuttle in player uniform, 2025
Shy Tuttle, NFL nose tackle, photo dated 2025‑09‑01.Photo: Tennessee Titans · CC BY 3.0

Facts drawn from Wikipédia, told in our own words.

2026 cap number
1.08 M$
Average per year
1.30 M$
Total value
1.3 M$
Seasons left
1 · through 2026

Cap number: the season's salary plus the share of the signing bonus spread over the contract. Total value and average per year cover the whole contract, from its signing.

Advanced stats, 2026 Interior defensive line

NFL stats →

2026 season, in progress (9 games played). The percentile ranks the player among regular interior defensive line: 90th means better than 90% of them.

Tackles

20

42th percentile

Sacks

2.0

65th percentile

Pressures

—

QB hits

2

9th percentile

Tackles for loss

4

64th percentile

Forced fumbles

0

39th percentile

Passes defended

0

23th percentile

Missed tackle rate

—

Defensive snaps

243

0th percentile

Games

9

Regular season. Data: nflverse (play-by-play, snap counts), Next Gen Stats, Pro Football Reference. EPA: expected points added. CPOE: completion percentage over expected.

2026 end-of-season projection

NFL trends →

Projected WAR

0.1

80% of cases: 0.0 to 0.2

Games

17

WAR 2026

0.0

Games played

9

WAR already earned, plus his pace (WAR per game over the last three seasons, 60/25/15, pulled toward the group average) over his team's remaining games, given his availability so far.

Trend

→ Stable (+1)

  • 2023-0.1 WAR · -0.006 per game
  • 2024-0.1 WAR · -0.007 per game
  • 20250.0 WAR · 0.000 per game
  • 20260.0 WAR · 0.000 per game

The trend compares this season's WAR per game with last season's, weighted by games played.

Outlook, age included

-14 · 30 y.o. · the age when performance usually declines

It is only a projection. It knows nothing about injuries, trades or role changes.

Player ratings, 2026

All ratings →

Ratings from 0 to 100 drawn from data, never by hand: 75 = established regular, 95+ = elite.

OV · Overall

67

Depth player

PRS
Pass rush
35
RDF
Run defense
79
TCK
Tackling
84
DUR
Durability
73
EX
Experience
75
Why these ratings?
  • PRS — Pass rush : Pressures, sacks and QB hits, per snap
  • RDF — Run defense : Run tackles and tackles for loss, per snap
  • TCK — Tackling : Tackles made and missed tackles
  • DUR — Durability : Games played out of his team's, over several seasons
  • EX — Experience : Seasons in the NFL

WAR and PAL Rating, 2026

How we rate →

WAR: the EPA (expected points added) of every play, above replacement level, shared among those who made it, then converted to wins (35.3 points = one win). PAL Rating scores performance from 0 to 100 against regulars in the same group (50 = median).

PAL: dimensions

Pass rush26
Run defense85
Splash plays62
Tackling80

Where WAR comes from (in wins)

Splash plays+0.01

Half the EPA of his sacks, interceptions, passes defended, forced fumbles, tackles for loss and QB hits, against his position's average per snap.

Coverage0.00

Yards allowed per target against his position's average, 0.12 points per yard (measured).

Position share+0.03

Replacement level: the share of defense the league spends on his position (by payroll), prorated by snaps.

Team defense0.00

How much better or worse than average his team's defense was (EPA allowed), minus what is already credited to players, prorated by snaps.

The individual part is splash plays and coverage. The rest is the position share and his team's defense, split by snaps played.

Season by season
SeasonTeamGWARPALOVTklSacksPrssTFL
2026WAS90.06567202.0—4
2025WAS120.03057150.0—1
2024CAR15-0.1663440.030
2023CAR17-0.1967390.510
2022NO170.13573442.031
2021NO170.13371470.052

Shy Tuttle: frequently asked questions

What are Shy Tuttle's stats in 2026?

Shy Tuttle has 2 sacks and 2 QB hits in 9 games in 2026.

How old is Shy Tuttle?

Shy Tuttle is 31 years old: he was born on October 20, 1995.

How tall is Shy Tuttle, and how much does he weigh?

Shy Tuttle is 6'3" (191 cm) and weighs 300 lb (136 kg).

Where is Shy Tuttle from?

United States: Shy Tuttle was born in Midway, NC, in the United States.

What team does Shy Tuttle play for?

Shy Tuttle plays for the Washington Commanders in the NFL, at DT, wearing number 96.

How good is Shy Tuttle?

Shy Tuttle produced 0.0 wins above replacement (WAR) in 2026 (season in progress). His PAL rating is 65 out of 100: above average for his position.

How much does Shy Tuttle make?

Shy Tuttle earns $1.3M for the 2026 season. His Value Rating is 75 out of 100 (very good contract): it measures the on-field return for that salary, compared with players at his position.

Is Shy Tuttle overpaid?

No, he gives more than he costs. His Value rating is 75 out of 100 (very good contract), where 50 is the output expected for his salary, compared with players at his position.

Is Shy Tuttle getting better?

Yes: his PAL rating went from 30 in 2025 to 65 in 2026 (out of 100, 50 = average player at his position).

Is Shy Tuttle related to anyone famous?

Yes: Perry Tuttle (uncle, former professional wide receiver).

What is Shy Tuttle's nationality?

Shy Tuttle is American.

Where did Shy Tuttle play before turning pro?

North Davidson High School; selected for the 2015 Under Armour All‑American Game; played four seasons for the Tennessee Volunteers (college football).

What is Shy Tuttle's projection for 2026?

Our projection has him at 0.1 WAR over the full 2026 season, based on his weighted recent seasons and age.

See also: his Washington Commanders teammates

Full roster →