PickALeague.com
1BaseKool-Aid McKinstry headshot

Kool-Aid

McKinstry

CB · NO · Very poor

PAL
18
WAR
-0.1
Value
40
TKL
35

2026№ 66 / 84

Kool-Aid McKinstry

#1CBNew Orleans Saints logoNew Orleans Saints

Biography

Team
New Orleans Saints
Position
Cornerback
Height
5' 11"
Weight
199 lbs
Born
September 30, 2002 (24)
Birthplace
Birmingham, AL
College
Alabama
Draft
2024: Rd 2, Pk 41 (NO)
Experience
3rd Season
Status
Active

NFL record

YearTeamGPTOTSOLOASTSACKFFFRYDS
2026New Orleans Saints93520150000
2025New Orleans Saints177659170000
2024New Orleans Saints154232100000

Kool-Aid McKinstry: our analysis

2026 season: 9 GP, 35 TKL, 0.0 SACKS, 0 TFL, 0 INT, 6 PD. WAR -0.1 (66th of 84) · PAL 18, very poor.

In 2026, Kool-Aid McKinstry, 24, posts a PAL Rating of 18 out of 100 (very poor), and his WAR of -0.1 ranks 66th among 84 regulars, in the bottom quarter.

On the other hand, splash plays (1, among the weakest in the league) and ball skills (15, among the weakest in the league) hold him back.

Breaking down his WAR (in wins), his biggest contribution: positional (+0.1); his biggest cost: splash plays (-0.1).

A marked decline: his PAL was 49 in 2025, against 18 now; his WAR went from 0.2 to -0.1.

Contract-wise, his Value score of 40 (poor return) weighs his output against what he costs: 50 is what that salary should buy.

Kool-Aid McKinstry's story

Growing up in Birmingham, McKinstry came into the spotlight at Pinson Valley High School, where he played both ways and produced eye-catching numbers as a senior: 12 pass breakups, two interceptions returned for touchdowns on defence, and 45 receptions for 706 yards and 11 scores on offence. Those achievements led to Alabama Mr. Football and the 2021 USA Today Defensive Player of the Year award, and he entered college ranked as a five-star prospect before committing to Alabama.

At the University of Alabama from 2021 through 2023, McKinstry made an immediate impact by appearing in every game as a freshman and earning a place on the SEC All-Freshman team after recording 25 tackles, a sack and an interception. He continued to develop into a primary cover option; in 2022 he led the SEC with 15 passes defended. His 2023 campaign culminated in first-team All-American honours, after which he declared for the 2024 NFL Draft.

The pre-draft process included a setback when a right-foot fracture was revealed on March 1, 2024, preventing him from taking part in the Combine, though he planned to participate in Pro Day activities. The New Orleans Saints selected McKinstry with the 41st overall pick in the 2024 draft. Early in his NFL tenure he produced a standout performance in Week 5 of the 2025 season, posting four tackles, three passes defensed and two interceptions in a 26–14 win over the New York Giants, and earning NFC Defensive Player of the Week.

McKinstry's game is defined by disruption of the passing attack: his college statistics—particularly leading the conference in passes defended—show a player who anticipates routes and contests catches. Off the field, his lifelong nickname “Kool-Aid,” given by his grandmother, became part of his public profile when he signed a Name, Image and Likeness agreement with Kool-Aid while a freshman at Alabama.

Facts drawn from Wikipédia, told in our own words.

2026 cap number
2.50 M$
Average per year
2.29 M$
Total value
9.2 M$
Seasons left
2 · through 2027

Cap number: the season's salary plus the share of the signing bonus spread over the contract. Total value and average per year cover the whole contract, from its signing.

Advanced stats, 2026 Cornerbacks

NFL stats →

2026 season, in progress (9 games played). The percentile ranks the player among regular cornerbacks: 90th means better than 90% of them.

Interceptions

0

24th percentile

Passes defended

6

50th percentile

Targets in coverage

20

Yards allowed

149 yd

Yards allowed per target

7.5 yd

44th percentile

Passer rating allowed

91.5

45th percentile

Tackles

35

60th percentile

Missed tackle rate

—

Tackles for loss

0

17th percentile

Defensive snaps

570

80th percentile

Regular season. Data: nflverse (play-by-play, snap counts), Next Gen Stats, Pro Football Reference. EPA: expected points added. CPOE: completion percentage over expected.

2026 end-of-season projection

NFL trends →

Projected WAR

0.0

80% of cases: -0.1 to 0.3

Games

17

WAR 2026

-0.1

Games played

9

WAR already earned, plus his pace (WAR per game over the last three seasons, 60/25/15, pulled toward the group average) over his team's remaining games, given his availability so far.

Trend

→ Stable (-4)

  • 20240.0 WAR · 0.000 per game
  • 20250.2 WAR · 0.012 per game
  • 2026-0.1 WAR · -0.011 per game

The trend compares this season's WAR per game with last season's, weighted by games played.

Outlook, age included

+21 · 23 y.o. · usually still improving

It is only a projection. It knows nothing about injuries, trades or role changes.

Player ratings, 2026

All ratings →

Ratings from 0 to 100 drawn from data, never by hand: 75 = established regular, 95+ = elite.

OV · Overall

71

Established starter

COV
Coverage
72
BAL
Ball skills
69
TCK
Tackling
66
DUR
Durability
83
EX
Experience
40
Why these ratings?
  • COV — Coverage : Yards and passer rating allowed per target
  • BAL — Ball skills : Ball carrier: fumbles avoided. Defender: interceptions and passes defended
  • TCK — Tackling : Tackles made and missed tackles
  • DUR — Durability : Games played out of his team's, over several seasons
  • EX — Experience : Seasons in the NFL

WAR and PAL Rating, 2026

How we rate →

WAR: the EPA (expected points added) of every play, above replacement level, shared among those who made it, then converted to wins (35.3 points = one win). PAL Rating scores performance from 0 to 100 against regulars in the same group (50 = median).

PAL: dimensions

Coverage60
Ball skills15
Splash plays1
Tackling16

Where WAR comes from (in wins)

Splash plays−0.11

Half the EPA of his sacks, interceptions, passes defended, forced fumbles, tackles for loss and QB hits, against his position's average per snap.

Coverage0.00

Yards allowed per target against his position's average, 0.12 points per yard (measured).

Position share+0.08

Replacement level: the share of defense the league spends on his position (by payroll), prorated by snaps.

Team defense−0.03

How much better or worse than average his team's defense was (EPA allowed), minus what is already credited to players, prorated by snaps.

The individual part is splash plays and coverage. The rest is the position share and his team's defense, split by snaps played.

Season by season
SeasonTeamGWARPALOVINTPDYds/tgtRtg allowed
2026NO9-0.11871067.591.5
2025NO170.249763178.2100.5
2024NO150.03670067.389.0

Analysis

Kool-Aid McKinstry: frequently asked questions

What are Kool-Aid McKinstry's stats in 2026?

Kool-Aid McKinstry has 0 interceptions and 6 passes defensed in 9 games in 2026.

How old is Kool-Aid McKinstry?

Kool-Aid McKinstry is 24 years old: he was born on September 30, 2002.

How tall is Kool-Aid McKinstry, and how much does he weigh?

Kool-Aid McKinstry is 5'11" (180 cm) and weighs 198 lb (90 kg).

Where is Kool-Aid McKinstry from?

United States: Kool-Aid McKinstry was born in Birmingham, AL, in the United States.

What team does Kool-Aid McKinstry play for?

Kool-Aid McKinstry plays for the New Orleans Saints in the NFL, at CB, wearing number 1.

How good is Kool-Aid McKinstry?

Kool-Aid McKinstry produced -0.1 wins above replacement (WAR) in 2026 (season in progress), 77th of 84 players at his position in the NFL. His PAL rating is 18 out of 100: very poor for his position.

How much does Kool-Aid McKinstry make?

Kool-Aid McKinstry earns $2.3M for the 2026 season. His Value Rating is 40 out of 100 (poor return): it measures the on-field return for that salary, compared with players at his position.

Is Kool-Aid McKinstry overpaid?

Yes, his output falls short of what his salary should buy. His Value rating is 40 out of 100 (poor return), where 50 is the output expected for his salary, compared with players at his position.

Is Kool-Aid McKinstry a top-10 player at his position?

No: by WAR, he ranks 77th of 84 players at his position in the NFL in 2026. Our comparison tool puts him side by side with any other player.

Is Kool-Aid McKinstry getting better?

No, he is slipping: his PAL rating went from 49 in 2025 to 18 in 2026 (out of 100, 50 = average player at his position).

Where was Kool-Aid McKinstry drafted?

Kool-Aid McKinstry was drafted in 2024 by NO, in round 2 (pick 41 of the round).

Which player is most similar to Kool-Aid McKinstry?

Maxwell Hairston: he is the player at his position whose PAL profile (the 0-to-100 dimensions) is closest to his in 2026.

Maxwell Hairston's page →

What is Kool-Aid McKinstry's nationality?

Kool-Aid McKinstry is American.

What awards has Kool-Aid McKinstry won?

USA Today High School Football Defensive Player of the Year (2021) ; Alabama Mr. Football (senior) ; SEC All‑Freshman team (2021) ; First‑team All‑American, Associated Press (2023) ; NFC Defensive Player of the Week (Week 5, 2025).

What is Kool-Aid McKinstry's nickname?

He is nicknamed "Kool‑Aid".

Where did Kool-Aid McKinstry play before turning pro?

Pinson Valley High School (Pinson, Alabama); Alabama Crimson Tide (college football), 2021–2023.

What is Kool-Aid McKinstry's projection for 2026?

Our projection has him at 0.0 WAR over the full 2026 season, based on his weighted recent seasons and age.

See also: his New Orleans Saints teammates

Full roster →