PickALeague.com
18BaseJ.J. McCarthy headshot

J.J.

McCarthy

QB · NYG · Around average

PAL
55
WAR
0.3
Value
65
YDS
915

2026

J.J. McCarthy

#18QBNew York Giants logoNew York Giants

Biography

Team
New York Giants
Position
Quarterback
Height
6' 3"
Weight
219 lbs
Born
January 20, 2003 (23)
Birthplace
La Grange Park, IL
College
Michigan
Draft
2024: Rd 1, Pk 10 (MIN)
Experience
3rd Season
Status
Active

Career history

  • New York Giants · 2026 (1 season)
  • Minnesota Vikings · 2025 (1 season)

NFL record

YearTeamGPCMPATTCMP%YDSAVGTDINT
2026New York Giants56610463.59158.822
2025Minnesota Vikings1014024357.61,6326.71112

J.J. McCarthy: our analysis

2026 season: 5 GP, 66 CMP, 104 ATT, 915 YDS, 2 TD, 2 INT. WAR 0.3 · PAL 55, around average.

In 2026, J.J. McCarthy, 23, posts a PAL Rating of 55 out of 100 (around average), with a WAR of 0.3.

His strengths: deep passing (94, among the best in the league) and accuracy (74, above average). On the other hand, rushing (19, well below average) and decisions (26, below average) hold him back.

Breaking down his WAR (in wins), his biggest contribution: passing (+0.4); his biggest cost: rushing (-0.1).

A clear step forward: his PAL went from 4 in 2025 to 55; his WAR went from -0.5 to 0.3.

Contract-wise, his Value score of 65 (good value) weighs his output against what he costs: 50 is what that salary should buy.

J.J. McCarthy's story

Growing up in La Grange Park, McCarthy left Nazareth Academy for IMG Academy after Nazareth’s 2020 season was canceled; he had already helped Nazareth reach back-to-back state finals and claimed a state title in 2018, then went 8–0 at IMG and earned a consensus high-school national championship.

A five-star recruit in the composite rankings, McCarthy committed to Michigan in May 2019 and enrolled in 2021. He began his college career as a backup, appearing in 11 games that freshman year and providing a late-season spark in the Orange Bowl that set up a quarterback competition heading into 2022.

Named Michigan’s starter in 2022, McCarthy steered the Wolverines through consecutive Big Ten titles and key victories over Ohio State, throwing for multiple-touchdown games and producing efficient passing lines across the season. In 2023 he posted several of his best statistical outings, recorded an outstanding completion percentage in early-season games, and helped Michigan to an undefeated 15–0 season. He was the Rose Bowl Offensive Player of the Game after the overtime win over Alabama and then guided the Wolverines to the national championship victory over Washington.

Across three seasons at Michigan the team won three Big Ten crowns and reached the College Football Playoff semifinals each year; McCarthy finished with a 27–1 record as a starter, the highest winning percentage in FBS history. Those achievements made him a top prospect for the NFL draft, and the Minnesota Vikings selected him 10th overall in 2024. A knee injury kept him out for his entire rookie year; he became the Vikings’ starter in 2025, but a combination of inconsistent performances and further injuries cost him the job in 2026 and precipitated a trade to the New York Giants.

McCarthy’s game blends clean decision-making with dual-threat ability: he can move his feet to create plays and deliver timely throws in pressure moments, qualities that defined his college success and shaped his early professional trajectory.

J. J. McCarthy with a shopping cart full of items at Target
Josh Liljenquist and J. J. McCarthy during a community-support shopping project at Target, 8 February 2025.Photo: Ingrid Liljenquist · CC0
J. J. McCarthy standing with two others before a community pizza outreach
Josh Liljenquist, J. J. McCarthy and Josh Hedquist at OG Zaza before a community pizza outreach in Roseville, 27 January 2025.Photo: NorthStarJoshL26 · CC0
J. J. McCarthy celebrating after the 2023 Big Ten Championship game win
Michigan Wolverines quarterback J. J. McCarthy after the 2023 Big Ten Championship game victory over the Iowa Hawkeyes, 3 December 2023.Photo: Maize & Blue Nation · CC BY 2.0
J. J. McCarthy in action during the 2021 season opener at Western Michigan
Image from the Michigan vs. Western Michigan game, 4 September 2021 (UM_Western_09.04.21_1177).Photo: Maize & Blue Nation · CC BY 2.0

Facts drawn from Wikipédia, told in our own words.

2026 cap number
0.90 M$
Average per year
5.46 M$
Total value
21.9 M$
Seasons left
2 · through 2027

Cap number: the season's salary plus the share of the signing bonus spread over the contract. Total value and average per year cover the whole contract, from its signing.

Advanced stats, 2026 Quarterbacks

NFL stats →

2026 season, in progress (5 games played). The percentile ranks the player among regular quarterbacks: 90th means better than 90% of them.

EPA per dropback

+0.13

66th percentile

CPOE

+3.3 %

77th percentile

Passing yards

915

0th percentile

Completion %

63.5 %

42th percentile

Yards per attempt

8.8

94th percentile

Passing TDs

2

0th percentile

Interceptions

2

98th percentile

Sacks taken

10

100th percentile

Rushing yards

85

34th percentile

Games

5

Regular season. Data: nflverse (play-by-play, snap counts), Next Gen Stats, Pro Football Reference. EPA: expected points added. CPOE: completion percentage over expected.

2026 end-of-season projection

NFL trends →

Projected WAR

0.5

80% of cases: -0.2 to 1.2

Games

9

WAR 2026

0.3

Games played

5

WAR already earned, plus his pace (WAR per game over the last three seasons, 60/25/15, pulled toward the group average) over his team's remaining games, given his availability so far.

Trend

↑ Slightly up (+18)

  • 2025-0.5 WAR · -0.050 per game
  • 20260.3 WAR · 0.060 per game

The trend compares this season's WAR per game with last season's, weighted by games played.

Outlook, age included

+43 · 23 y.o. · usually still improving

It is only a projection. It knows nothing about injuries, trades or role changes.

Player ratings, 2026

All ratings →

Ratings from 0 to 100 drawn from data, never by hand: 75 = established regular, 95+ = elite.

OV · Overall

35

Backup or prospect

PAS
Passing
67
ACC
Accuracy
56
DEC
Decisions
35
DEP
Deep ball
80
MOB
Mobility
67
DUR
Durability
51
EX
Experience
40
Why these ratings?
  • PAS — Passing : Expected points added per dropback, success rate
  • ACC — Accuracy : Completion percentage over expected (CPOE), on-target throws
  • DEC — Decisions : Interceptions and sacks avoided
  • DEP — Deep ball : Production on throws of 20+ air yards
  • MOB — Mobility : Value of his runs
  • DUR — Durability : Games played out of his team's, over several seasons
  • EX — Experience : Seasons in the NFL

WAR and PAL Rating, 2026

How we rate →

WAR: the EPA (expected points added) of every play, above replacement level, shared among those who made it, then converted to wins (35.3 points = one win). PAL Rating scores performance from 0 to 100 against regulars in the same group (50 = median).

PAL: dimensions

Passing55
Accuracy74
Decisions26
Deep passing94
Rushing19

Where WAR comes from (in wins)

Passing+0.37

60% of the EPA of his throws to a receiver, 75% of his sacks, throwaways and scrambles, above replacement.

Rushing−0.06

45% of the EPA of his carries (the line gets the rest), above replacement.

Season by season
SeasonTeamGWARPALOVPass ydsTDINTEPA/db
2026NYG50.3553591522+0.13
2025MIN10-0.54531,6321112−0.15

J.J. McCarthy: frequently asked questions

What are J.J. McCarthy's stats in 2026?

J.J. McCarthy has 915 passing yards, 2 touchdown passes and 2 interceptions in 5 games in 2026.

How old is J.J. McCarthy?

J.J. McCarthy is 23 years old: he was born on January 20, 2003.

How tall is J.J. McCarthy, and how much does he weigh?

J.J. McCarthy is 6'3" (191 cm) and weighs 218 lb (99 kg).

Where is J.J. McCarthy from?

United States: J.J. McCarthy was born in La Grange Park, IL, in the United States.

What team does J.J. McCarthy play for?

J.J. McCarthy plays for the New York Giants in the NFL, at QB, wearing number 18.

How good is J.J. McCarthy?

J.J. McCarthy produced 0.3 wins above replacement (WAR) in 2026 (season in progress). His PAL rating is 55 out of 100: around average for his position.

How much does J.J. McCarthy make?

J.J. McCarthy earns $5.5M for the 2026 season. His Value Rating is 65 out of 100 (good value): it measures the on-field return for that salary, compared with players at his position.

Is J.J. McCarthy overpaid?

No, he gives more than he costs. His Value rating is 65 out of 100 (good value), where 50 is the output expected for his salary, compared with players at his position.

Is J.J. McCarthy getting better?

Yes: his PAL rating went from 4 in 2025 to 55 in 2026 (out of 100, 50 = average player at his position).

Where was J.J. McCarthy drafted?

J.J. McCarthy was drafted in 2024 by MIN, in round 1 (pick 10 of the round).

What is J.J. McCarthy's nationality?

J.J. McCarthy is American.

What awards has J.J. McCarthy won?

Big Ten Quarterback of the Year honors (as stated in the article) ; Rose Bowl Offensive Player of the Game (January 1, 2024) ; NFC Offensive Player of the Week (for his performance in the 2025 NFL season opener).

How many championships has J.J. McCarthy won?

4: College national champion with Michigan, 2023 season (15–0, won the National Championship); Three Big Ten titles with Michigan (the program won conference titles in each of his three years: 2021, 2022, 2023); Illinois state championship with Nazareth Academy (state title won in 2018); Consensus high school national championship with IMG Academy (senior season 2020, 8–0).

Where did J.J. McCarthy play before turning pro?

Nazareth Academy (high school, two seasons as starter, 26–2) then IMG Academy (senior year, 2020, 8–0, consensus high school national championship); University of Michigan (Michigan Wolverines, 2021–2023)..

What is J.J. McCarthy's projection for 2026?

Our projection has him at 0.5 WAR over the full 2026 season, based on his weighted recent seasons and age.

See also: his New York Giants teammates

Full roster →